This was also my first submission for publication, and I responded positively to almost every suggestion made by the reviewers. The article underwent significant revisions, except for one experiment that I did not want to include. This led to a negative response, and ultimately, my paper was rejected by both the initial reviewer and a new reviewer added in the second round of review. Ironically, one month after the rejection, I was invited to review a paper

(0) 讚！ | Ren

I don't feel motivated anymore

(0) 讚！ | sunshinecmsj

Still didn't go up this year

(0) 讚！ | tjust

As a flagship journal in the industry, I don't know when it will be included in the second division of the Chinese Academy of Sciences

(0) 讚！ | abccba

October 2023 - Submit initial draft. Return for major revisions in December.
January 2024 - Submit revised draft. Return for minor revisions in February.
March 2024 - Submit final draft. Acceptance in April.
The initial feedback on the draft made me question everything, but after putting in a lot of effort to make changes, it was finally accepted

(0) 讚！ | xjtupanda

How long have you been waiting to hear back? It's been 6 months and I haven't heard anything, they haven't replied to my emails either

(0) 讚！ | flyingbird2022

Too slow, and can't contact the journal

(0) 讚！ | lljaza

I also submitted my paper on June 6, 2023, and it is still under review as of November 24. There has been no response to my emails. It seems that there are too many submissions for the reviewers to keep up with, leading to a backlog that will result in stricter scrutiny in the future

(0) 讚！ | flyingbird2022

Bro, it's been six months for me too. I've emailed them for inquiries but no one has replied. What's going on with this journal?

(0) 讚！ | lljaza

OP, what's going on? Why did minor repairs turn into rejection, scary /(ㄒoㄒ)/~~ (Research novice

(0) 讚！ | xxxx7

January 13, 2023 submit
February 10, 2023 under review
August 2, 2023 major revision (1 major 1 minor)
September 17, 2023 resubmit
November 9, 2023 reject (1 minor 2 reject

(0) 讚！ | Ren

Submitted on 2023-6-20. It's been five months since the first trial and there is still no result. I sent an email to inquire about it but haven't received any response yet. Feeling uneasy

(2) 讚！ | RhyThm87

2022.12 submit
2023.9 major revision (2*minor+1*major)
2023.10 revision submitted
CVPR extended paper, rejected by TMM, TCSVT, I have to complain about these two journals. It seems like they are very picky about extended papers, but don't mind accepting whatever is submitted by an AE. Maybe they just like to swim in top conferences (laughs). I submitted to TOMM at the end of last year, this journal is mainly categorized by the Chinese Academy of Sciences, but it also has a CCF-B and Trans title. Personally, I feel that it's much better than some CCF-C journals, maybe not as good as the top-tier ones, but still better in comparison. Nowadays, most reputable computer science programs in good schools still prioritize CCF. However, the review process is indeed a bit slow, which is a serious mismatch with the three-month first review claimed on the official website. It's clearly 8 months, isn't it? Just submitted the revision, hoping for smooth progress

(1) 讚！ | ron_at_ust

Submit by 2023-10-05

(0) 讚！ | xjtupanda

First review: 3.5 months) (Second review: 1 month) (Third review: 0.5 months), with an additional 2 months for major revisions, totaling 7 months.
The speed is acceptable, with three reviewers, high level but many issues. TOMM has a higher level. Major revisions are given 2 months for revisions, while minor revisions are given 1 month for revisions

(5) 讚！ | rice0531

Submitted on September 15, 2022. Status: under review.
Received feedback after waiting for three months on December 8, 2022. Two reviewers, one major revision, one minor revision, with two months given for modifications.
First round of revisions completed and manuscript returned on January 29, 2023 (slower process due to Chinese New Year), status: under review.
Waited for a full six months until August 1, 2023, when status changed from under review to awaiting decision.
Received feedback from second round of review after six months on August 6, 2023 (minor revision), two reviewers, one acceptance; one raised two minor issues.
Manuscript returned after second round of revisions on August 11, 2023. Status: under review.
... Continued waiting, 
Nearly a year has passed, it feels like the second reviewer has changed, and it's so sad that after all this time there's still a need for a second review, who knows how much longer I'll have to wait. I'm so sad

(1) 讚！ | 特别想接收文章

I have passed both TMM and TOMM. On average, TMM is more difficult, but occasionally I come across some impressive articles on TOMM, mainly written by foreigners. TMM has very few such articles, while TOMM has gained a high level of recognition internationally.

(0) 讚！ | GAO-MONT

Feeling that TMM is a bit difficult, after all, it's top in the first district.

(0) 讚！ | tjust

May I ask which one is better between this journal and TMM?

(0) 讚！ | xxxx7

However, in many places in the country, job hunting is mainly based on the division of areas rather than the prestige of institutions like CCF-B, which makes it difficult. Moreover, the self-citation rate is so low, even IEEE transactions have a self-citation rate of around 15.

(0) 讚！ | tjust

It has been five months since my second review, and there is still no news. I feel really sad. I have also sent reminders but haven't received any replies. I'm so upset that I could cry.

(0) 讚！ | 特别想接收文章

It is rare to see an increase in Impact Factor (IF) despite having such a low self-citation rate. Many journals achieve an increase in IF by citing their own articles, leading to a high self-citation rate. Those who understand the process know this well. Other journals hesitate to submit articles that are not cited by them.

(0) 讚！ | jingbao

This partition, let's talk about it. It's really just that the editor-in-chief is Chinese and the IF will rise immediately.

(0) 讚！ | jingbao

The impact factor has exceeded 5. Is there a possibility to reach the second zone this year?

(0) 讚！ | tjust

If the editor is a Chinese, it will soon be possible to be promoted to the first or second district.

(0) 讚！ | abccba