Does this journal only communicate through emails for notifications? I submitted my paper but haven't received any email updates.

(0) 讚！ | 雪灵

The review process lasted a total of 5 months, which is not considered fast.
27 October 2025       With Journal Administrator
03 November 2025   With Editor
14 November 2025   Out for Review
02 February 2026     Revision Required
22 February 2026     Revised Manuscript Submitted
22 February 2026     With Journal Administrator
23 February 2026     With Editor
02 March 2026         Out for Review
26 March 2026         Decision Pending
27 March 2026         Accepted

(0) 讚！ | Ma Hang

April 17, 2025 Manuscript Submitted
April 17, 2025 With Journal Administrator
April 24, 2025 With Editor
April 30, 2025 Out for Review
May 22, 2025 Decision Pending
May 30, 2025 Revision Required
June 24, 2025 Revision Incomplete
June 24, 2025 Revised Manuscript Submitted
June 24, 2025 With Journal Administrator
June 25, 2025 With Editor
July 05, 2025 Out for Review
July 21, 2025 Decision Pending
July 24, 2025 Accepted - Three months from submission to acceptance.

(0) 讚！ | sssssz

Submission in May 2025
Reviewed by the end of June 2025
Pending decision by the end of July 2025
Major revisions in late August 2025 (yes, delayed by a month)
Returned for revisions by the end of September 2025
Pending decision by the end of November 2025
Accepted by the end of December 2025
Overall, the process was not fast, but the editorial board was quite efficient.

(0) 讚！ | 通过通过通过

It has been 8 days since I resubmitted the manuscript with the editor for the first round of revisions.

(0) 讚！ | 通过通过通过

Do you have any news? It has been almost two months since my second round of revisions with the editor, and I have not received any updates.

(0) 讚！ | Mengfan0821

30 January 2025        Manuscript Resubmitted
02 February 2025      With Editor
11 February 2025       Out for Review
11 April 2025              Revision Required
24 May 2025              Revised Manuscript Submitted
26 May 2025              With Editor
30 May 2025              Out for Review
02 July 2025               Revision Required
16 July 2025               Revised Manuscript Submitted
03 September 2025    With Editor
04 September 2025    Accepted

(0) 讚！ | 2642

Excuse me, what is the outcome? My pending decision has been pending for almost a month.

(0) 讚！ | 哈娜

The decision has been pending for over 10 days and there is still no result. What is the situation? Has anyone who has submitted experienced this before?

(0) 讚！ | Joe

Congratulations, Accept!

(0) 讚！ | CADAAA

I sent an email to the magazine explaining the situation, and the next day they sent me their editorial feedback.

(0) 讚！ | yoya

Also revised, with the editor. I don't know why this journal is particularly slow. The first round took almost half a year, and it has been over two months for the second round. I estimate it will not be finished in less than a year or so.

(0) 讚！ | dd

One thing, mine is also in "with editor", I don't know why this journal is particularly slow.

(0) 讚！ | dd

How is the article going? I have also been editing it for about a month and there hasn't been any progress.

(0) 讚！ | IloveJN

May I ask what is the current status of your article? It has been with the editor for over two months now.

(0) 讚！ | yang8023

May I ask what is the current status of your article? It has been over two months since my first round of revisions, and it is still "with editor."

(1) 讚！ | yang8023

You are so fast!

(0) 讚！ | dd

Mine is the same. How do you handle it?

(0) 讚！ | zhangye01

Can you tell me why my submission interface has changed to a status that requires modification, but I have not received any email notification about it? What should I do?

(0) 讚！ | yoya

Overall very fast, thanks to the editor. 
10 May 2024 manuscript submitted
23 May 2024 with Editor
29 May 2024 out for review
10 June 2024 decision pending
12 June 2024 revision required
09 July 2024 revised manuscript submitted
09 July 2024 with editor
10 July 2024 out for review
17 July 2024 decision pending
18 July 2024 revision required
25 July 2024 revised manuscript submitted
31 July 2024 with editor
01 August 2024 out for review
01 August 2024 decision pending
05 August 2024 accepted

(1) 讚！ | 旧日红1992

January 15, 2024    Manuscript Submitted
January 26, 2024    Out for Review
March 18, 2024       Reviews Complete
April 02, 2024          Decision Pending
April 04, 2024          Revision Required
July 14, 2024           Revised Manuscript Submitted
August 06, 2024       With Editor
August 06, 2024        Out for Review
August 08, 2024        Reviews Complete
August 08, 2024        Decision Pending
August 09, 2024         Accepted

(0) 讚！ | 滴答-抵达

The process was challenging and very professional.

26 March 2024 With Journal Administrator
29 March 2024 With Editor
22 April 2024 Out for Review
25 April 2024 Decision Pending
26 April 2024 Revision Required
17 May 2024 Revised Manuscript Submitted
17 May 2024 With Journal Administrator
31 May 2024 With Editor
17 June 2024 Out for Review
11 July 2024 Decision Pending
11 July 2024 Revision Required
12 July 2024 Revised Manuscript Submitted
12 July 2024 With Journal Administrator
17 July 2024 With Editor
07 August 2024 Accepted

(0) 讚！ | LOGIC

May I ask what is your current status?

(0) 讚！ | dd

I am not sure about the submission status of this magazine. I have not completed the reviews yet. Once I send it out for review, it will be pending decision. It has been a month already

(0) 讚！ | dd

The external review has been going on for over two months. After the review was completed, I have been waiting for a decision for over three months now, but still haven't heard anything. I don't know if the editor-in-chief forgot or what's going on. I sent an email requesting to withdraw the submission, but there has been no reply. It's really causing delays

(0) 讚！ | 哈哈哈哈25