Non-double-first-class universities, supervisors are not top scholars, working on explosive shock wave direction. Submitted to this journal three times, two times directly rejected by the desk. After being sent for review, both reviewers suggested minor revisions but were rejected by the editor. The two reviewers provided a total of 6 comments, with 4 of them related to formatting. Just providing this as a reference for everyone.

(2) 讚！ | maomao111

Agreed!! My four reviewers, one gave minor revisions, the other three suggested modifications, all within manageable range. And then directly rejected by the editor-in-chief! The main reason is that the four reviewers have reviewed for so long, and there are no fundamental issues. It not only wastes the time of the reviewers but also delays the graduation time for students! It is recommended to be cautious when submitting for graduation!!

(0) 讚！ | GGP

Two major revisions were given, although they were major revisions, a total of eight suggestions were provided, two-thirds of which were about formatting issues or the need for detailed explanation of certain parameters. Both reviewers praised the innovation of the paper, but the editor rejected it on the grounds of lack of innovation. The purely subjective feeling is that there is a serious problem of clique mentality, although it appears to be a comprehensive journal, most of the content is focused in related fields. Before submitting, it is recommended to check if there are few papers related to your direction in the journal, then it is not advisable to consider submitting.

(1) 讚！ | 陈昱杰

There is a processing fee for submissions.

(0) 讚！ | 一二三亖

Have any of you encountered this situation when submitting contributions?

(0) 讚！ | kkdd_001

Excuse me, is this journal actually charging fees? The editor mentioned a publication fee of 9500 when sending me the need for confidential review.

(0) 讚！ | wyffyw

Does this journal charge any fees? The editor mentioned a publication fee of 9500 when sending me the manuscript for confidential review.

(0) 讚！ | wyffyw

Is this journal chargeable? When discussing the need for confidential review, a publication fee of 9500 was mentioned.

(0) 讚！ | wyffyw

Received 26 August 2025
Received in revised form 24 November 2025
Accepted 25 December 2025

(0) 讚！ | 紫菜蛋花汤

Be cautious in investing, lack of direct innovation will result in immediate rejection.

(0) 讚！ |

Please contact Avast customer service.

(0) 讚！ | 喜欢学术的小小小

How can I check the progress of the review for this journal? I couldn't find it on the Elsevier public account, is there any other way to do so?

(0) 讚！ | 日常搬砖的研究生

Hello, I would like to ask if this publication accepts contributions from all fields of national defense, or if it focuses on specific areas.

(0) 讚！ | 会议论文

My application status shows "Decision in Process" since January 16, 2026, and it's already the 12th today. Chinese New Year is coming soon, I hope it won't be delayed until after the New Year to be accepted.

(0) 讚！ | WeOK

I want to ask my friend, do I need to include recommended reviewers in the Cover Letter when submitting a manuscript?

(0) 讚！ | Optimus123

I want to ask my friend, do we need to include recommended reviewers in the cover letter when submitting a manuscript?

(0) 讚！ | Optimus123

Agreed, AI review, question any questionable areas once, then give major revisions. In the eyes of the editor, major revisions equal rejection.

(0) 讚！ | 草原小勇士

I suggest everyone be cautious about submitting to this journal. It is extremely out of line, with AI reviewers providing highly templated feedback that is all about summarizing and criticizing. They offer many amateur suggestions, such as comparing my work on radar anti-jamming with YOLO transformer, which is an obvious AI. The managing editor is also clueless and has a bad attitude, and the review process is extremely lengthy. It is indeed necessary to be cautious when submitting to domestic journals like this, as the waters are too deep.

(0) 讚！ | yanyiyi

Translation: Avoiding lightning, although submitted for review in seconds, both reviewers' feedback is for revisions. At this point, the editor may also reject the submission, stating that "major revisions are needed, so the submission is rejected." If this happens twice, it is no longer considered an exception.

(0) 讚！ | Shisanling

May I ask where can I find the names of the reviewers? The system only shows "under review" and I can't find any information on the Elsevier official account.

(0) 讚！ | 冷暖双剑

Reply to everyone:
1. For the paper Word template, please check the official account of DT, it is recommended to use Word and Visio content for easy modification after acceptance;
2. The BM review form can be in Chinese, using the template from your school, there is no fixed format. You need to submit first, and then the editorial department will contact the corresponding email address;
3. After submitting the paper, each email will receive a notification, but not everyone needs to confirm. It is just for information. Confirming only allows that email to see the progress, nothing more.
4. There are usually 3 reviewers, but I have also seen some with 2 or even 5. It may depend on the direction of expertise.
5. The review process for this journal usually takes 1-2 months. Do not rush the editors, inquire about the review progress with the Elsevier customer service;
6. Regarding universities, the main focus is on the quality of the article. Any article submitted to a journal may be rejected, regardless of the institution. If you are capable, you can publish in Nature without considering the reputation of the institution.
7. There will be a page fee, around 10,000 RMB, which needs to be paid by your supervisor or yourself. Payment is due one week after acceptance, and it takes about a month to receive the invoice.
8. After acceptance, the paper will only be published online (not yet indexed in WOS). It will take approximately 6-9 months for the official publication and SCI indexing, so please keep this in mind.
9. When writing the article, emphasize both theoretical and experimental aspects, focusing on novelty and experimentation.

(1) 讚！ | 喜欢学术的小小小

Very good, the domestic journal has just been promoted to Zone 1, and the review speed is relatively fast with 2 reviewers; of course, if it crosses

(0) 讚！ | X-Y

Is there a publication fee for this journal?

(0) 讚！ | linshan_666

How much does it cost?

(0) 讚！ | HJH小小何

Translate this paragraph into English: Rmre这个

(0) 讚！ | 挖煤人cumtb