Submission experience:
2025/8/20 submitted
2025/8/20 Rejected with Resubmit
2025/9/19 resubmitted
2025/10/31 Major Revisions
2026/1/28 resubmitted
2026/3/28 Accepted

(0) 讚！ | Tarimo

Hello, I have replied to AE's email.

(0) 讚！ | Accept

Can I ask for the link to the old version of the system?

(0) 讚！ | Berlinyuuu

Hello, do I need to provide a response when resubmitting after expanding on relevant work and literature?

(0) 讚！ | zyc_1128

Additional note: After the submission of the Major Revision, an additional reviewer was added, and their opinion was to accept the manuscript.

(0) 讚！ | Accept

The journal has potential, the editors are responsible, the review comments are professional, worth submitting!

2025-3-3 Submitted
2025-3-3 Revise and Resubmit as "New" (no assigned reviewers, only AE comments, need to expand literature review)
2025-4-25 Resubmitted
2025-6-19 With Editor
2025-7-5 Undergoing review
2025-7-14 Major Revision (three reviewers, one accept, one major revision, one minor revision)
2025-10-12 Submitted (due to personal reasons, delayed until the deadline)
2025-12-11 Accept

(0) 讚！ | Accept

Submitted an article, the acceptance speed was relatively fast. The quality of this journal is very high, and the reviewers' comments on the paper were very pertinent. After carefully revising, it was accepted.

(0) 讚！ | 框框中论文

I had submitted an article about machine learning before, and it was accepted for publication about half a year later. The reviewer's comments were very insightful, and the journal's standards are quite high.

(0) 讚！ | 拜佛中论文

Submitted an article, took half a year to be accepted. The journal has high requirements for papers, and the reviewers are very responsible, providing many valuable suggestions.

(0) 讚！ | longtimeforever

2025-4-submit
2025-5-Major Revisions
2025-7-submit
2025-8-Minor Revisions
2025-9-submit
2025-10-accept
Contact the manager for more information on the revisions, understand the exchange of ideas.

(0) 讚！ | ZZJ

On February 20th, the manuscript was submitted and received initial feedback on the same day, requesting additional work and a significant expansion of the reference list.

Revised on February 28th.

Received first-round feedback on March 30th, with three reviewers giving evaluations of fair, good, and excellent respectively. The final decision was to reject and resubmit.

Revised as requested on May 15th.

Received second-round feedback on June 27th, with a notice for major revisions.

Revised on July 9th (as R1).

Received third-round feedback on August 13th, with a new manuscript number. Two reviewers recommended acceptance, one recommended rejection, and the editor decided to reject and resubmit.

Persuaded the reviewers and revised again on August 23rd.

Received fourth-round feedback on October 8th, for major revisions, with the deputy editor requesting further expansion of the reference list and no reviewer comments.

Revised on October 16th.

Received the final decision on October 17th, which was acceptance.

(0) 讚！ | JOKERLANCER

2024.10 First submission;
2025.3 Rejection and resubmission;
2025.7 Revision requested;
2025.8 Major revision;
2025.9 Revision requested;
2025.10 Accepted without revisions.

(1) 讚！ | Ryanhx

May I ask how to submit the response letter for a rejected manuscript for reconsideration to ensure that the reviewers can see it?

(0) 讚！ | Ryanhx

First submission on November 26, 2024;
Rejection and resubmission on February 14, 2025;
Revision returned on March 31, 2025;
Rejection and resubmission on May 21, 2025; (mainly due to the transition of systems, which caused my response to not be seen by the reviewers)
Returned on June 17, 2025;
Minor revisions on August 17, 2025;
Returned on September 15, 2025;
Formally accepted on October 10, 2025;
Overall, I feel that the editors of TNSE are very attentive, and their email responses are very quick. The review process for these submissions was all completed within two months. Thumbs up, and best wishes for continued success.

(0) 讚！ | more

Overall, the submission experience was excellent. I will consider submitting again next time.

(0) 讚！ | 树哲

June 24, 2025 - minor
August 21, 2025 - Accept

(0) 讚！ | 树哲

Okay, thank you. Found it. Does "undergoing review + double ADM" mean it's under review? What is the next status? Please advise.

(0) 讚！ | 芝麻开门开门

You can see it by logging into the old submission system.

(0) 讚！ | ZXNzxn1

Hello, may I ask where did you see such detailed submission status? I am currently using the new system, and after submitting, it shows "under review" instead of "undergoing review". Did you see it in the old system? Could you please provide a link?

(0) 讚！ | 芝麻开门开门

Hello, may I ask where did you see such detailed submission status? I am currently using the new system, and after submitting it goes directly under review. Did you see it on the old system? Could you please provide a link?

(0) 讚！ | 芝麻开门开门

2024-11-19 submit
2025-2-17 Major Revisions
2025-6-15 submit
2025-7-26 Minor Revisions
2025-7-28 submit
now Under review

After the major revisions were submitted, the status has been continuously under review, and the minor revisions are currently also under review.

(0) 讚！ | L先生

The same goes for me. The first major revision is undergoing review, while the second minor revision is under review.

(0) 讚！ | L先生

2024-7-31 Undergoing Review
2024-12-15 Major Revisions Required (4 reviewers)
2025-3-15 Resubmitted
2025-4-15 Major Revisions Required (3 reviewers accepted, 1 requested changes)
2025-5-26 Resubmitted
2025-7-1 Accept

It took a total of 11 months, with the first major revision wasting two months due to personal reasons. The initial review took about 4 months, and each major revision was given ample time (3 months). Responses were typically provided within about a month after resubmission.

(1) 讚！ | 星河2024

8.31 Undergoing review
9.5 Double ADM
1.7 With editor
1.15 Major Revisions Required
3.25 Submit & Undergoing review
5.6 With editor
5.8 Minor Revisions
5.20 Submit & Undergoing review
6.27 Accept

(0) 讚！ | 夜竹枫林

The first time, two minor revisions, one major revision, and a resubmit were requested. 
The second time, with a new editor and reviewer, three major revisions were requested before resubmitting. 
Finally, after two major revisions and one minor revision, it was accepted but then rejected, which was very frustrating.

(0) 讚！ | judge-x