The review process was very fast, and the feedback provided by the experts was very insightful and directly addressed the key points.

(0) 讚！ | totorr

May I ask how long has it been Under Review?

(0) 讚！ | yszjl

The suggestions made by the editor are very insightful, hitting the nail on the head.

(0) 讚！ | perfect

Submitted in August 2023
Revised once in September 2023, the reviewers were very professional and meticulous
Revised four times in October 2023, the editor gradually refined the paper based on the reviewers' feedback, made changes according to the editor's requirements, including polishing
Published in December 2023
The entire submission and revision process was quite cumbersome, but the feedback was very fair and professional. The final draft was indeed much more refined than when it was first submitted, including improvements in language expression.

(1) 讚！ | perfect

Journal published by Chinese people, to be honest, the review speed is okay. Although the articles were rejected, I must comment on the unimpressive professional level of the reviewers. Both reviewers did not read the article carefully. The review comments clearly addressed their doubts, but the reviewers obviously did not take a serious look. In the end, they rejected it because of nonexistent so-called issues. It's really a waste of time and I am quite disappointed with this journal.

(6) 讚！ | chenzhuer33

It has been over two months. The editor said they couldn't find reviewers. How miserable! The senior students in the research group revised their papers in less than a month! Worth mentioning is that the speed of the editor's response is really fast. I sent a reminder email and received a reply in less than two hours.

(1) 讚！ | 寺牧