It's been two days, isn't this journal quite fast?

(0) 讚！ | 秋重

Still in the process of editing, estimated to be completed by the end of the month.

(0) 讚！ | SCI一投就中

Did my brother win?

(0) 讚！ | 秋重

The submission sent on May 11th was with the editor the next day. The external reviewer's comments were received within 20 days.

(0) 讚！ | SCI一投就中

Excuse me, OP, on which day did you submit your article for review, May 10th? And did you receive revision suggestions on May 31st?

(0) 讚！ | superman123

Submission in December, review by one reviewer in January, major revisions requested in February;
Revised submission in March, reviewed by two reviewers, returned in April for major revisions;
Revised submission in April, reviewed by three reviewers, rejected in June.

(0) 讚！ | 圆卷卷19

I feel quite lucky this time. The reviewing expert was lenient, always with a grateful heart.

(0) 讚！ | SCI一投就中

Good luck to the original poster. May I ask what direction the original poster is in? What are the main aspects of understanding the direction that journals are easily submitted for review (I feel it may change over time)?

(1) 讚！ | WQC

Received feedback on the 31st that is very professional and basically said that it can be submitted to the top experts in this industry (direction).

(0) 讚！ | SCI一投就中

I submitted my work on May 10th, and now it is under review. Keeping my fingers crossed, hoping it will bring me good luck. It is an honor for me to have my work reviewed, praying for blessings.

(0) 讚！ | SCI一投就中

My time with you is very close, submitted on December 26th, 24 years old, returned for revision on March 11th, major revision, submitted again on April 5th, and accepted on May 14th.

(0) 讚！ | 漫步云海涧

2024.12.26 Submitted
2024.12.26 2→0
2024.12.31 2→1
2025.01.07 3→1
2025.01.11 3→1/1
2025.01.16 4→1/1
2025.01.20 4→1/2
2025.02.26 4→2/2
2025.03.03 Major revised
2025.04.07 Revised resubmitted
2025.05.14 Accept
Overall, the editorial process was very fast, with reviewers invited on the same day as submission. However, the topic may be niche, making it difficult to find reviewers. Ultimately, the paper was accepted after five months.

(0) 讚！ | 房山季鸟猴

Apr 12, 2025, Under Review (2 review invitations sent, 2 review invitations accepted, 0->1 review completed)
Apr 22, 2025, Required Reviews Completed (2 review invitations sent, 2 review invitations accepted, 2 reviews completed)
Apr 22, 2025, Revise (Editor has given MAJOR REVISIONS and requested resubmission by May 6, one reviewer has agreed to accept, another reviewer has provided 3 comments)
Apr 28, 2025, With Editor
Apr 29, 2025, Under Review (1 review invitation sent, 0 review invitations accepted, 0 reviews completed)
Apr 30, 2025, Review Complete (1 review invitation sent, 1 review invitation accepted, 0->1 review completed)
Apr 30, 2025, Completed - Accept

(0) 讚！ | Geotechnics5454

Feb 16, 2025, Under Review (3 review invitations sent, 2 accepted, 0->1 completed)
Feb 19, 2025, Required Reviews Completed (3 review invitations sent, 2 accepted, 1->2 completed)
Feb 19, 2025, Revise (Editor requested MAJOR REVISIONS and return revised manuscript by April 20, with a total of 21 comments from two reviewers)
Mar 28, 2025, With Editor, delayed by some miscellaneous matters, otherwise could have been revised faster
Mar 29, 2025, Under Review (0->2 review invitations sent, 0 accepted, 0 completed)
Mar 30, 2025, Under Review (2 review invitations sent, 0->1 accepted, 0 completed)
Apr 3, 2025, Under Review (2 review invitations sent, 1->2 accepted, 0 completed), bug on the "Elsevier Publishing Service" WeChat account from March 30 to April 10 did not send notifications.

(0) 讚！ | Geotechnics5454

CG is the top journal in our field, it's really good and fast! Thanks to Editor-in-Chief John S McCartney and the two peer reviewers for raising professional questions that greatly improved the quality of the manuscript. The specific submission process is as follows:
Jan 09, 2025, Submitted to Journal
Jan 10, 2025, With Editor
Jan 10, 2025, Under Review (Review invitations sent: 2, Review invitations accepted: 0, Reviews completed: 0)
Jan 15, 2025, Under Review (Review invitations sent: 2->3, Review invitations accepted: 0, Reviews completed: 0)
Jan 20, 2025, Under Review (Review invitations sent: 3, Review invitations accepted: 0->1, Reviews completed: 0)
Jan 25, 2025, Under Review (Review invitations sent: 3, Review invitations accepted: 1->2, Reviews completed: 0)

(0) 讚！ | Geotechnics5454

20241120 Submitted / With editor
20241121 Under review
20241231 Required Reviews Completed
20250102 Revise
20250227 Revisions being processed
20250421 Decision in process / Accept

The editor responded promptly, feedback could be received almost on the same day; because the topic is relatively niche, the opinions of the two reviewers (presumably compatriots) were not very relevant, but still difficult to change; the revision period coincided with the Spring Festival, so it took two months to submit the revisions; after the revisions, it seems to have caught up with the busy season for our researchers, so we are truly grateful to the reviewers for taking the time to re-review our manuscript. In recent years, the quality of CG's output has been good, and we hope that everyone's submissions will be fruitful ^_^*

(0) 讚！ | hanfeiwork

Everyone for me, I for everyone.

(0) 讚！ | 李——

The second one has been under review for a month now, I don't know what the result will be, so I can only wait.

(0) 讚！ | ZYS

Same question, where can I check the review status?

(0) 讚！ | ZWY-

Submitted to Journal: 2024-02-26
With Editor: 2024-02-28
Under Review: 2024-02-29
Rejected: 2024-03-30

(0) 讚！ | nature副主编

Where can I see how many reviewers have approved the review? It cannot be found in the official account, and there is no link for checking the status of the paper.

(0) 讚！ | peridynamic

I had two reviewers at that time.

(0) 讚！ | ForsakenMe

I have sent out 3, one is under review, and the remaining two have no updates, not sure if they will continue to be sent.

(0) 讚！ | ZYS

I am now also, one month to complete a review, and then sent for another month, still not found, just directly ended the review.

(0) 讚！ | 南充

Several reviewers.

(0) 讚！ | 南充