Have you got any results yet? I submitted on 7.16 and it is still with the editor.

(0) 讚！ | 咋搞捏？

Indeed, this journal is a bit strange, as no one besides the author can see the review process progress.

(0) 讚！ | Jeenching

The first round involves three reviewers and major revisions. The second round involves two reviewers, with one major revision and one acceptance. The third round involves one reviewer and major revisions. The fourth round involves one reviewer.

(0) 讚！ | lgdzjy

The fourth round of review was rejected. Three days ago, I even sent it for external review, but the reviewers had not even received my response, and Jung-Wuk Hong, the editor, rejected it directly. The reason given was lack of novelty and they have received too many articles. Speechless. It was submitted before the Chinese New Year, and now half a year has passed like this.

(0) 讚！ | lgdzjy

April 20, 2026 Submitted to WE
April 22, 2026 Under review by editor
May 17, 2026 Major revision requested by RRC on the same day
May 26, 2026 Revised and resubmitted to WE
May 28, 2026 Under review by editor
June 18, 2026 Under review by RRC
June 20, 2026 Accepted

This is the second time submitting to this journal, with the last submission being in 2023. The entire submission process took exactly two months, and I appreciate the quick handling of the manuscript by Professor Jung-Wuk Hong, the editor from South Korea.

The feedback from the three reviewers was mostly positive, all of whom are peers in the relevant field. There were a total of 13 comments, which were addressed in a few days before resubmission.

The journal's Impact Factor has now risen to 6.3, and the CiteScore is also in the top 10%. I wish the journal continued success and increasing influence.

(0) 讚！ | z乐意

The first revision was completed, and after the rework, all three reviewers agreed to accept the submission. However, there are still some formatting issues that need to be fixed before resubmission. It has been over 20 days now, and the status is still "With Editor". Sending reminder emails has not been successful. Beware of the chief editor P** I**.

(0) 讚！ | sajiasheng

I remember rejecting pretty quickly, and I switched to.

(1) 讚！ | 嘤嘤嘤小喇叭

Hello, may I ask if this journal is reviewed quickly this year?

(0) 讚！ | 一口华子定乾坤

Hello, I would like to ask if there is any progress.

(0) 讚！ | 麦当劳肯德基哪个好吃

I have already been rejected twice by other journals, each time taking a month. I hope this journal can be faster.

(1) 讚！ | 落尘尘

Excuse me, what is your number? I'm currently debating whether to apply for this, as it seems like the acceptance rate is very low. Are you still at STJ?

(0) 讚！ | XIANGYU LI

How many days has it been with the editor? Has it been submitted for review?

(0) 讚！ | zgchxj

I have been submitting for several days, but the Status Date has not changed. The editor has not reviewed it yet. The editorial team of this small journal is understaffed, so once the submission volume increases slightly, it becomes backlogged. Now we can only wait and hope that the editor will review it quickly.

(0) 讚！ | zgchxj

I can't see the status, and I can't see my work either. Submitted WE on 4.22. Currently no results.

(0) 讚！ | Yousayyds

Only the corresponding author can view it.

(0) 讚！ | 嘤嘤嘤小喇叭

Could I ask the submission experts, is the first author unable to view the status of the manuscript in the system, and only the corresponding author can view it? I closed the webpage before the PDF was generated when submitting the manuscript, and then the corresponding author approved it. However, I do not have online information about the manuscript on my end. Is this normal?

(0) 讚！ | 比耶2

Hello, may I ask if the first author is unable to view the status of the manuscript in the system, and only the corresponding author can check it?

(0) 讚！ | 比耶2

Korean editing is going viral. Submitted on January 28th, reviewed on January 31st, and consistently contacted potential contributors twice a week. Regardless of whether the review comments are completed or need revisions, they are dealt with on the same day. Accepted on March 28th. Wishing your publication greater success in the future.

(0) 讚！ | wyx2333

A few days after submission, it was sent for review, during which 13 reviewers were contacted but none reviewed the manuscript. It was rejected directly one month later. However, we are still grateful to the editor from Korea for their high efficiency in handling the submission. Hope to meet again in the future.

(0) 讚！ | 冬马kaze

We are very slow, taking 13 days, and the result returned does not meet the journal's scope.

(0) 讚！ | king_tiger

I submitted quite a lot. I submitted my manuscript on the 19th of last month, and the manuscript number is already over 1950. 
10.19 submitted
10.23 under review, reviewed by 2 people
10.28 added another reviewer
11.06 reviewed by 2 people completed

(0) 讚！ | 骑着狼放羊

Brother, are there many reviewers? Which reviewer should I choose to get a quicker review? I see some posters below have been waiting for 24 years for their submissions to be reviewed, it's really slow.

(0) 讚！ | Ddavinci

How come you're so fast~ I submitted 10 days ago and it's still with editor.

(0) 讚！ | 张馍馍

Record of submission process:
2025.06.28 with editor
2025.06.28 under review
2025.07.23 required review completed
2025.07.25 major revision
2025.08.19 with editor
2025.08.20 under review
2025.09.04 required review completed
2025.09.06 accept

The journal's processing speed is very fast. You can choose the editor Hong Zhengxu from South Korea, who is very efficient. There were a total of four reviewers, one directly rejected the submission, while three provided revision suggestions. There were a total of 23 suggestions, and one month was given for revisions. The questions raised by the experts were very good, and the revisions were completed in about half a month. However, due to personal vacation, the revisions were only sent back on the 19th. It took 70 days from submission to acceptance, and I was quite happy to submit to SCI for the first time. Thanks to the editor and reviewers.

(0) 讚！ | zgh0220

Do you need a double-blind mode?

(0) 讚！ | yiyiww