I was only two or three days in, but I waited for over two weeks for Awaiting Editor Assignment.

(0) 讚！ | Shuyeeeee

Awaiting track editor assignment, how many days does this status require?

(0) 讚！ | zzz快快毕业吧

Has there been any change in your Underreview status? It has been almost three months since the submission, and it has been Underreview the whole time without any changes.

(0) 讚！ | zxyzxy123

May I ask if there has been any change in your Underreview status? It has been almost three months since you submitted your application, and it has remained Underreview with no updates.

(0) 讚！ | zxyzxy123

This classification may not be accurate, after all, the Chinese Academy of Sciences has not said it recognizes this classification. If the Chinese Academy of Sciences recognizes it, then it is the Chinese Academy of Sciences' classification.

(0) 讚！ | Abermethy

Just hired and already demoted to the second tier.

(0) 讚！ | 神奇的米酒

The journal is a good journal, no problem, just too slow. Here is my record for your reference.

02-11-2024 Submitted
05-11-2024 Awaiting recommendation
22-3-2025 Major Revision
10-4-2025 A revision has been submitted
15-6-2025 Minor Revision
01-7-2025 A revision has been submitted
20-3-2026 Awaiting recommendation
21-3-2026 Accept

(0) 讚！ | 霸道的屁屁

2026.3.7 Awaiting Editor Assignment
Has the situation remained the same until now?

(0) 讚！ | 宋星星

I have been waiting for 7 months for my submission, but it is still under review. I have followed up once, and was told that one of the reviewers has not responded yet. Has anyone else experienced this situation?

(0) 讚！ | 小伊轻舟

It has been two weeks and the status "Awaiting Recommendation" has not changed. Is this normal?

(0) 讚！ | Wenkai Jin

I am now almost three months old, when did you finally come out?

(0) 讚！ | bxt

It seems like there is no progress yet. The submission was made in early December and now it is awaiting recommendation in early January.

(0) 讚！ | Ken_Hu

I have been under review for four and a half months after submitting my contribution. Has anyone else experienced this situation?

(0) 讚！ | 小伊轻舟

2025.6.29. Submit Manuscript.
2025.8.6. Major Revision.
2025.11.20. Submit R1.
2025.12.2. Minor Revision.
2025.12.27. Submit R2.
2026.1.3. Accept.

Encountered 6 reviewers, with 3 minor revisions, 2 major revisions, and 1 strong rejection. A total of 28 questions needed to be addressed. The questions from both minor and major revisions were very professional, while the questions from the rejection were particularly sharp, almost making one want to give up. However, the editor decided for a major revision. It took over three months to supplement the simulation, re-test in the darkroom, and polish the language of the article, with a submission in late November. Ten days after submission, received minor revision results, with the reviewer who initially strongly rejected changing to minor revision, raising 4 new questions and providing suggestions on the language of the article. After completing the response in late December, received acceptance notification a week later.

The review process was fast, with reviewers being especially professional, carefully examining the article's content, key references, and providing their own opinions. After experiencing this half-year battle, I truly understand why TAP is considered a top journal in the antenna field.

(1) 讚！ | dsawd

It has reached the point where even teachers are exhausting all resources to provide students with a quality article, leading to a mix of good and bad journal quality.

(0) 讚！ | Alice&Isabella

Can I ask if submitting the application will go directly to Under Review status? Which status represents the application being sent for review?

(0) 讚！ | 666

03-Mar-2025 提交
27-Jul-2025 等待推荐
28-Jul-2025 重大修订
28-Sep-2025 已提交修订
01-Dec-2025 等待推荐
05-Dec-2025 接受

Translation:
03-Mar-2025 Submitted
27-Jul-2025 Awaiting recommendation
28-Jul-2025 Major Revision
28-Sep-2025 A revision has been submitted
01-Dec-2025 Awaiting recommendation
05-Dec-2025 Accepted

(0) 讚！ | maoyu摸鱼佬

After obtaining approval from the editorial department, it is permitted to resubmit.

(0) 讚！ | SummerJeff

This is simply a miracle, is September 26th "reject but allow resubmission"?

(0) 讚！ | weizhang2025

2025.4.8 Submission
2025.5.25 Major revision
2025.7.7 Revision
2025.7.31 Second round of major revision
2025.9.3 Revision
2025.9.18 Rejection
2025.9.26 Resubmission
2025.11.19 Major revision
2025.12.3 Acceptance
Persistence is victory!

(0) 讚！ | SummerJeff

I have made minor revisions for the second review and have been waiting for recommendations for three weeks. Is the journal editor not going to handle this?

(0) 讚！ | 张庭森

How did it go? It's been almost two weeks since my AR.

(0) 讚！ | fuhao_01

How did it turn out?

(0) 讚！ | fuhao_01

5.29 Submission
7.12 Major Revision
10.24 Minor Revision
11.1 a revision has been submitted
11.2 Accept
The reviewers are very professional, and the editorial process is now very fast.

(1) 讚！ | zzz

4.16 Submission
6.05 Major revision
9.28 Revisions requested
10.13 Minor revision
10.17 Revisions requested
11.02 Acceptance

For authoritative journals in the field of antenna, don't try to get by with deception! Thanks to the reviewers and editors, every revision suggestion helps improve the quality of the manuscript!

(0) 讚！ | 资深投稿人