Boss, do all reviewers have minor revisions in the second round of review?

(0) 讚！ | 等待

Not a big shot, just a noob. In the first round, there were 3 reviewers, two good and one bad, and the bad one was convinced. However, my senior and I had the same situation in the first review, but he couldn't convince the bad reviewer. In the second review, there were 5 reviewers, with 1 having no comments; the remaining two were split between good and bad. The third review has not yet been completed.

(0) 讚！ | lucky DES

Boss, I want to ask, how many reviewers are usually assigned to TAC? I have been under review for 4 months, and I am quite nervous as the feedback is coming back today.

(0) 讚！ | Henry

Can we still go back to District One after 26 years? This zoning system of the Chinese Academy of Sciences is really annoying.

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

The first trial will basically take about half a year.

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

Submitted in August 2024
Rejected upon first review in February 2025 and resubmitted
Accepted with conditions in August 2025
Fully accepted in mid-November 2025
Commemorating the first TAC during the doctoral stage, the review process was too long. It is best not to submit if you are close to graduation. If you still have two years until graduation, you can give it a try.

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

The first TAC of my doctoral career. Commemorating the submission process:

2024.12.09 submit;
2025. 01.15 under review;
2025. 05. 25 Decision pending;
2025. 05 .27 Provisionally rejected;
Three reviewers, over 50 questions, all focused on how to improve the paper. For example, one meticulous reviewer not only pointed out the issues but also told me how to address them. The response letter was 32 pages long.
2025. 07. 02 resubmit;
2025 .07. 05 under review;
2025. 10. 31 Decision pending;
2025. 11. 02 accepted for publication as a Full Paper.

(0) 讚！ | lucky DES

Good luck, my little apprentice has been missing for over two months, and there has been no news at all.

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

The same, all very slow, basically starting from one year.

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

Bro, may I ask how long does the first instance take?

(0) 讚！ | Two_dog

2024.04.14 Submit
2024.04.28 Under review
2024.11.23 Reject - may be resubmitted as Paper [3P]
2024.12.13 Resubmit
2024.12.19 Under review
2025.05.19 Decision pending
2025.05.20 Conditionally accepted as Paper [2P]
2025.05.20 Resubmit
2025.05.23 Under review
2025.10.01 Decision pending
2025.10.01 Accepted without changes as Paper [1P]

National Day gift 555, decision made within half a day by the editor, although minor revisions for review took over 4 months which was time consuming.
The reviewers of TAC are the most conscientious, professional, strict in terms of content and lenient in terms of format that I have ever encountered. They focus on the actual innovation and correctness of the content, providing many suggestions for writing and presentation, but not rejecting the submission as a result. My doctoral research has been inspired by the feedback from TAC reviewers on many occasions, and I hope TAC continues to improve.

(0) 讚！ | 小同学TCL

Can any expert share their experience in submitting short articles to TAC? Is the peer review process for short articles in this journal faster than for long articles?

(0) 讚！ | Two_dog

Yes, long articles are needed, but not short ones.

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

Do we need to include the author's photo and bio when submitting a long article?

(0) 讚！ | Xzq12

Hello, if the conditions for acceptance are met, do we need to make changes according to each reviewer's comments, or just address the issues raised by the editor? Will the acceptance still be rejected under the conditions?

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

There is no distinction between upper and lower case.

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

20 days

(0) 讚！ | thoren

My first submission was assigned a second reviewer, but the second and third submissions were not. However, regardless of whether a second reviewer was assigned or not, the review process was extremely slow.

(0) 讚！ | 小同学TCL

May I ask how long it took for the status to change to "under review" at the end?

(0) 讚！ | 天空地海一体化

Hey, how long after receiving the submission do you typically start the review process? It's been half a month for me and it's still under review.

(0) 讚！ | 天空地海一体化

Is there a reviewer for the second review? It's been two months since my second review, it's too slow...

(0) 讚！ | 爱数学的小伟同学

Hello, the short essay is a Technical Note (no more than 8 pages).

(0) 讚！ | 小同学TCL

2025.05.02 submit
2025.05.14 received

How come it has been 12 days since submission and it is still not under review? Is something wrong.. feeling anxious.

(0) 讚！ | thoren

Is there a difference between uppercase and lowercase? Which one represents sending it for external review?

(0) 讚！ | naaisi

Cow, even after winning, continues to invest. Impressive.

(0) 讚！ | asfev