May I ask how long it takes for you to provide review comments in this state? I have been stuck in this state for three months now, still in the review process.

(0) 讚！ | Xxiong

It's really too slow, it's been almost a year and it's still in the second trial, don't invest.

(0) 讚！ | changlixin

2024.12.6 new submission
2025.5.22 major revision R1
2025.6.20 revised manuscript submitted
2025.8.10 major revision R2
2025.8.27 revised manuscript submitted
2025.12.13 major revision R3
2025.12.18 revised manuscript submitted
2026.2.21 accepted
2026.4.4 proofreading & license agreement
2026.4.5 APC payment
2026.5.25 published

The manuscript was stuck in the editorial process after review and resubmission. The editorial work was meticulous, but due to busy daily tasks, the system progress was not updated in a timely manner. I sent a total of 15 emails to urge for updates, but the editor did not check them in time, and the editorial department's assistance in contacting was also unsuccessful, resulting in repeated delays in the process. After a long delay following the third round of revisions, the manuscript was finally sent to the editor-in-chief for review and was officially accepted. The copyediting process took one and a half months after acceptance, and it took another month and a half from copyediting to publication. This year and a half of the submission process was truly exhausting.

(0) 讚！ | cheonbak

3.20 STJ
4.3 UR
4.8 RC

(0) 讚！ | Chen

There are three reviewers in total. The first external review suggested major revisions, after the modifications were made, two reviewers accepted the changes, while one suggested minor revisions. However, the editor requested major revisions, which is confusing as to the standards of this journal.

(0) 讚！ | wwwww

28 Apr 2025 initial submission
18 Jun 2025 accept

(0) 讚！ | 科研小白jay

After submitting, the status changed from "under review" to "reviews completed," then back to "under review" on the same day. What's going on? Has anyone else experienced this? ?

(0) 讚！ | wwwww

It's been two months and the Editor is still not invited, why is it taking so long?

(1) 讚！ | 向钱冲

I have been submitting my manuscript for over a month now and still have not received an invitation from the editor. How long does it usually take for this journal to send manuscripts for review?

(0) 讚！ | 向钱冲

Has the review speed of this journal increased? I saw online reviews saying it takes 12 months, which seems a bit too long.

(0) 讚！ | yiming song

Hello, does this journal still require page charges? Did your submission go directly from Editor Invited to Reviews Completed without going through Under review?

(0) 讚！ | 向钱冲

Overall, it was quite fast, with less than two months from revisions to acceptance. Just not sure about the final page fees.
Timeline for submission, for reference:
22 Apr 2025 New Submission
25 Apr 2025 Editor assigned
27 Apr 2025 Editor Invited

9 May 2025 Reviews Completed
14 May 2025 Reviews Completed
15 May 2025 Major revisions
2 Jun 2025 New Submission
26 Jun 2025 Final Decision Acceptance

(0) 讚！ | 心之所往

Looking for a journal template

(0) 讚！ | 蒋太强

Is there a required rate for repeated submissions for this journal?

(0) 讚！ | 等待

How is your article coming along now?

(0) 讚！ | LYZ2543

After 25 days of the first review, the status changed to "editor assigned". What's going on? This seems too short, could it be a rejection?

(0) 讚！ | lucky paper

The case has not been through the second review yet. The first review took 2 months, and the revised version has been submitted. However, the second review has been in the "Under Review" status since "Reviewers Assigned." The status changed back to "Reviewers Assigned" a few days ago for unknown reasons

(0) 讚！ | robotman2021

First trial takes two months, second trial takes eight months, third trial is just a small issue, but it's been six months and still no news. Has anyone encountered this before?

(0) 讚！ | xlzh

I have encountered a problem now. After replying to the review comments, the manuscript keeps being sent back to me. The references in the submitted paper do not appear. Can I add your contact information?

(0) 讚！ | 面包脑袋

2022.11.03: Submission
2023.12.26: Repair and overhaul
2023.01.26: Resubmission for repair
2023.06.05: Accepted
The second review is taking so long, I thought it was rejected.

(2) 讚！ | Mayon

I would like to ask, on the official website, it mentions that this journal can be selected as open access. Does it require an article processing charge? How much is the article processing charge?

(0) 讚！ | 面包脑袋

May 7th submission
August 5th major repair
September 5th repair submission
November 29th acceptance

(0) 讚！ | JIALI777

First submission, four reviewers provided detailed comments, all of which required major revisions. However, unfortunately, due to AE rushing to meet the end-of-year target, they rejected the paper without providing any reasons. It is recommended not to submit or reference this journal!

(1) 讚！ | fhyyds

The initial review took 10 months, and it was rejected. This journal is extremely slow and garbage. Two inexperienced reviewers were found, probably pretending to understand the field, and they rejected it based on superficial issues. The editor of this journal is also terrible. It's a garbage journal.

(110) 讚！ | 哈哈哒

Has anyone submitted to this journal recently? Let's exchange some information.

(3) 讚！ | liuwuniu