You first submit the manuscript, and the editor-in-chief will contact you for other materials, but this process will take another month. The complete submission requires: 1. a statement that the manuscript has not been submitted to any other journal, 2. the pdf of the manuscript, 3. the tex of the manuscript, 4. a cover letter, 5. a list of the 6 most influential researchers in the field of the paper, 6. a list of the 10 most authoritative researchers in the field, 7. author information, with detailed institutional information required by the editor, 8. a similarity (plagiarism check) report, to be generated using Turnitin.

(0) 讚！ | 简瑟琳

Can I just submit the manuscript and cover letter for the first submission?

(0) 讚！ | suifeng666

2026/1/25 Received
2026/1/27 Proof

(0) 讚！ | 简瑟琳

Hired after modification on 13th January 2026. Only Reviewer 4 has two questions remaining.

(0) 讚！ | 简瑟琳

Submission can only be made via email. If you do not receive a reply, it may be because the recipient did not receive the email. 
On May 26, 2025, the submission was sent to editor-in-chief Adeli's email. 
On July 22, 2025, a reply was received requesting additional information, and the article entered the review process. 
On August 25, 2025, feedback from 5 reviewers was received, with two major revisions and three minor revisions. A three-week period was given for revisions. 
On September 16, 2025, the revised article was sent to the editor-in-chief's email, and on September 17, 2025, it was sent again. 
On December 17, 2025, an email was sent to inquire about the progress of the review, and the editor-in-chief informed that they did not receive the revised manuscript. 
On December 18, 2028, the revised feedback and manuscript in PDF and tex formats were returned via edu email, but the editor-in-chief still did not reply. 
On December 19, 2028, the same content was sent again via Gmail, and the editor-in-chief replied that they received it and it entered re-review. 
Therefore, if you do not receive a reply from this journal, it is likely that the recipient did not receive it. It is advisable to promptly send another email for confirmation or switch to a different email address for sending.

(0) 讚！ | 简瑟琳

How's it going, brother? Have you replied? I also sent an email but haven't received any response. They should at least reply to rejection emails, right?

(0) 讚！ | 皇叔多小衮

Is this the submission email: ?
It's been a month and there hasn't been any response at all!!
I used the school's .edu email system, which shows that it has been delivered to the recipient's email server.
Should I follow up on the submission?

(0) 讚！ | unicornroland

Submission email: adeli.1@osu.edu, correct?
It's been a month and still no response!!
I used the school's .edu email system, which shows that the submission has been delivered to the recipient's email server.
Should I follow up on the submission?

(0) 讚！ | unicornroland

Is this the email for submitting articles: ? 
It's been a month and there has been no response at all!! 
I used the school's edu email system and it shows that the email has been delivered to the recipient's server. 
Should I follow up on the submission?

(0) 讚！ | unicornroland

73 articles in one year, what are you thinking? No process yet...

(0) 讚！ | 慕白ss

There is no public process, which is very unfriendly to students, and the submission process is complicated.

(0) 讚！ | claJzL

The self-citation rate of 40% in this journal feels like there might be an issue.

(0) 讚！ | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

Hello, big shot. Is 7. The Conscientious Reviewer form for each author (except students) as a Word file in the submission guidelines required for all authors or only for those who want to be reviewers?

(1) 讚！ | 陈府

An email notification will be sent after the submission for review.

(0) 讚！ | xiaoxxkid

Will the editor-in-chief send an email notification after the paper is submitted for review?

(0) 讚！ | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

Submitted in mid-July 2024
Received a reply from the editor regarding formatting issues in less than a day, and after making corrections, the email entered "Under Review" in a little over a week.
Received the first round of comments in early October 2024 from 8 reviewers, with a one-month deadline. Requested an extension from the editor via email, which was granted.
Submitted responses to comments at the end of November 2024.
Accepted at the end of December 2024, received acceptance letter a few days later, and received proofs over a month later, with online publication following shortly after.
Since this journal only accepts email submissions, it was not possible to track the progress of the manuscript throughout the process, except for the editor's replies. However, the editor was quite responsible and usually provided feedback within a week (often within a day).

(0) 讚！ | xiaoxxkid

Hello, senior, I would like to inquire if this magazine only accepts submissions via email? How can I track the progress of my submission?

(0) 讚！ | 陈府

1. Submitted at the end of December in the 24th year.
2. First review comments in March of the 25th year. (5 reviewers, over 50 comments, four minor revisions, one major revision)
3. Second review comments in May of the 25th year. (5 reviewers, 5 comments, four accepted, one minor revision)
4. Revised manuscript resubmitted in May of the 25th year.
5. Accepted by the editor-in-chief.
6. Proofreading in June of the 25th year.

(0) 讚！ | libai1999

I would like to ask if your paper is open access? Can you provide more details? When was it submitted in January and when did you receive a response in April?

(0) 讚！ | 白帅

May I ask about the recognition of this journal (domestically/ internationally)? Why is the annual publication volume so low?

(0) 讚！ | wjz114

Hello, may I ask how to know the status of my submission?

(0) 讚！ | yanpengqian

Friends, how do we know the status of the review after submitting our contribution?

(0) 讚！ | CYLM

Excuse me, what is the submission website address?

(0) 讚！ | jjyifan

Self-citation rate of 31%???? This is the rhythm to immediately enter prestigious journals!

(0) 讚！ | xxyh

Hello! May I ask if this journal accepts submissions via direct email? How can I check the status of the review process?

(0) 讚！ | booya