2025.5.20 Submission
2025.7.7 Minor revisions
2025.7.23 External review
2025.8.6 Acceptance

(0) 讚！ | SHZUWJ

Please translate the following paragraph into English: 25.5.20投稿

Submission on May 25th, 2020

(0) 讚！ | SHZUWJ

Where can I see this detailed review status? Why can I only see the current status?

(0) 讚！ | 昵称

May I ask how many peer reviewers were invited for the external review? I invited 12 reviewers for my submission, but only one has agreed so far. Is this normal?

(0) 讚！ | 小李0515

Brother, after the status changes to "Your proof corrections have been returned to Elsevier," what else do we need to do? How long will your paper be online approximately?

(0) 讚！ | GXH1122

The journal review process is very fast and timely. It is important to note that recommended reviewers must include foreigners. My first stage was delayed for nearly a month for this reason.

(0) 讚！ | GXH1122

The journal efficiency is quite good, but the efficiency of reviewers is relatively low. It took a long time during the first review stage, but the processing was very fast after receiving the comments!

Submitted on 24.5.18
Supplemented the list of reviewers on 24.5.21
Sent for review on 24.5.28
Resubmitted for review on 24.7.07
Resubmitted for review on 24.7.23
Resubmitted for review on 24.8.18
Resubmitted for review on 24.8.22
Required reviewer comments completed on 24.8.29
Minor revisions on 24.9.09
Returned on 24.9.12
External review on 24.9.12
Required reviewer comments completed on 24.9.20
Accepted on 24.9.23

(0) 讚！ | ChengX

The first trial is relatively slow.

(0) 讚！ | ChengX

I did the same, inviting 6 reviewers, only one accepted and provided feedback, and then it just stalled. Bro, how are things going for you now?

(0) 讚！ | 一碗鸡汤

After editing, you may need to go back and make some modifications, it's okay.
Correction: Reviewers should not recommend only domestic reviewers, 1-2 foreign reviewers are sufficient.

(2) 讚！ | 小王1997

What!! Five reviewers from different countries? I recommended 5 Chinese people // Crying.

(0) 讚！ | yezi_2024

On April 10, 2024, the manuscript was submitted. Note: The journal requires that the 5 recommended reviewers must have different nationalities, otherwise the manuscript will be returned for resubmission. 

On April 16, 2024, it was sent for review. The review process was quick, but inviting reviewers was slow, with one reviewer being invited each week. 

On July 8, 2024, minor revisions were requested. On July 12, the revised manuscript was submitted. 

On July 16, 2024, it was sent for review again. On July 18, minor revisions were requested. 

On July 19, the revised manuscript was submitted. It was accepted on July 21, 2024. 

The first review process was slow, possibly due to waiting for other reviewers. The second review process was fast, with both editors and reviewers handling it promptly. Thumbs up to them. Finally, best wishes to everyone for a smooth submission process!

(2) 讚！ | 小王1997

Hello, how long did it take for your submission to go from "Submitted to Journal" to "with editor"? It has been 5 days since I submitted mine and it is still in the "Submitted to Journal" status. Also, how do you choose the editor and reviewers when submitting a manuscript?

(0) 讚！ | yezi_2024

Basic manpower in the nonlinear field, there is still influence and reputation

(0) 讚！ | 狂飙_NDyn

It has been 4 months since it was submitted. Only one reviewer accepted the review and returned feedback. It has been left like this, and there is no use in urging. This efficiency is too slow

(0) 讚！ | HengZhao

Submitted on January 17th, still waiting to be published in the journal. It's taking too long

(0) 讚！ | 安慕希

Submitted on September 15th, revised format in between.
Under review as of September 28th.
Heard that the review process is very slow...leaving a comment here as a memento

(0) 讚！ | rockU

Submitted on September 15th, received by the editor on the 22nd. This is my first submission, and I feel there is a high chance of rejection

(0) 讚！ | rockU

Submitted on August 12, 2023

(0) 讚！ | briareos

Why is the speed so slow? One reviewer recommended acceptance, while the other said the language needs polishing. The editor provided minor revisions to improve the language. After making careful revisions, the manuscript was submitted. It has been almost four months. Two reminders were sent in the meantime, but the editor asked for patience. 

December 9th: Manuscript submitted.
April 28th: Minor revisions.
May 7th: Revised manuscript submitted.
May 10th: Under review.
May 21st: One feedback received.
Three reminders were sent in the meantime, the editor's attitude was good, but no action was taken.

September 14th: Another reminder sent.
September 15th: Accepted.

(5) 讚！ | 御风而行

The review process is quite long, but the result is good!

(1) 讚！ | Daniele

Submission: September 11, 2021;
Feedback: November 22, 2021 (major revision);
Resubmission: December 12, 2021;
Acceptance: January 11, 2022.
Celebrating my first SCI publication! The feedback from the two reviewers wasn't too difficult. Just the review process was a bit slow.

(1) 讚！ | 华北山大王

The manuscript always displays "submitted to journals" after it was submitted several days ago. Does anyone who knows what’s going on?

(6) 讚！ | 一念执着

The review speed was fast, and the comments given by the reviewers were very professional, and the overall feeling was good.

(9) 讚！ | 德鲁大叔

It took a long time for this journal to review manuscripts. There has been no news for many years since my paper was submitted.

(0) 讚！ | eeee