I want to ask everyone, on the 19th it changed from STJ to WITH; on the 20th it remained WITH, but the date changed. Is the probability of rejection high in this situation? I have already been rejected once.

(0) 讚！ | kaier546

My article has also been in the hands of reviewers for half a month without any response.

(0) 讚！ | zqy123

7.16 Submission
9.1 Major revision
9.22 Rework
After National Day, the status of the manuscript has remained unchanged, under review, and the original reviewer has not accepted the invitation. I see people around me getting reviewed quickly, why is it so slow for me? I won't be able to graduate in the fall, so upset.

(0) 讚！ | RRRrrringo

Why can't other authors see the status of the paper after submission? Is it because of the journal, as other journals have status updates? Can anyone provide an explanation?

(0) 讚！ | 黑心白菜商

2026.4.21 submitted to the journal
2026.4.23 with editor (Editor: Shenghao Wang)
2026.5.17 under review - invited 12, accepted 1
2026.5.19 under review - invited 12, accepted 1, completed 1
2026.5.20 under review - invited 12, accepted 2, completed 1
2026.5.21 rrc completed 2
2026.6.21 major revision
2026.7.6 revised
2026.7.6 under review - invited 2
2026.7.8 under review - invited 2, accepted 2
2026.7.9 under review - invited 2, accepted 2, completed 1
2026.7.17 rrc completed 2
2026.7.19 major revision
2026.7.27 revised
2026.7.28 with editor
2026.7.29 major revision
2026.7.30 revised
2026.7.31 with editor
2026.8.9 minor revision
2026.8.11 revised
2026.8.12 accept

(0) 讚！ | 萌萌

666, I wrote a piece in the first half of the year, with a reply of 18000 words and 50 pages. This is the most I have submitted at one time since I started contributing. You are even more fierce.

(0) 讚！ | Wink~

Admire you. I have already received it. I also submitted before the Mid-Autumn Festival, and then took a break for 4 days, and now I am still in the review process. Three reviewers gave me nearly 80 comments. The revised manuscript is 140 pages long with 24,000 words.

(0) 讚！ | zqy123

2026.08.12 STJ
2026.08.22 WE
2026.08.24 WE
2026.08.31 UR
2026.09.12 Major revision with 2 experts' 17 comments due by 10.3. Still struggling with Reviewer 2's questions.
2026.09.27 Working continuously until the end of Mid-Autumn Festival for submission.
2026.09.29 UR
2026.10.06 AC

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

Received, but I can't see the specific options of each reviewer. I can only see the comments if there are any.

(0) 讚！ | WuSugai

After the proof was revised, the online version was sent to me directly. No one asked me about the layout fee, do you know why?

(0) 讚！ | WuSugai

How to say it now?

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

26.7.28 STJ
26.8.11 WE
26.8.12 UR (two reviewers)
26.8.28 RRC
26.9.4 Major revision, with a total of 10 comments from two minor revisions, editor gives major revision, with 20 days
26.9.13 Revised STJ
26.9.14 WE
26.9.15 UR
26.9.20 RRC
26.9.21 Accept
Efficient process, thanks to JAC.

(0) 讚！ | 0 to 0

After the first review, a total of 16 comments were received from three reviewers. After making revisions according to the comments, the editor still requested major revisions. Two of the reviewers did not provide any feedback, does this mean they have approved the manuscript? The third reviewer provided two suggestions which are currently being addressed. I would like to know if it is possible to see whether each reviewer has recommended acceptance or rejection for the journal.

(0) 讚！ | WuSugai

It's a bit slow, I've been waiting for a long time too.

(0) 讚！ | hhao

2026.8.12 STJ
2026.8.22 WE 2026.8.24 WE
2026.8.31 UR Check on the public account shows 7 invitations sent, 4 invitations accepted, and 1 review completed.

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

Submitted to journal: August 15th
With editor: August 20th
Under review: August 23rd
Require review complete: September 2nd
Rejected: September 3rd (2 revisions, 1 rejection)
The submission process was fast this time, but it was ultimately rejected. It seems like one of the reviewers was quite picky.

(0) 讚！ | 金宝小牛

What state are you in right now?

(0) 讚！ | zqy123

Soon, in less than two months, he was hired.

(0) 讚！ | Zhang7787

Yes, have the holidays started? I see that all the previous comments were posted on the same day and got the WE on the same day. If you're lucky, you'll get UR the next day.

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

We finally sent it out on the 26th after spending 4 days on it.

(0) 讚！ | zqy123