After the first review, a total of 16 comments were received from three reviewers. After making revisions according to the comments, the editor still requested major revisions. Two of the reviewers did not provide any feedback, does this mean they have approved the manuscript? The third reviewer provided two suggestions which are currently being addressed. I would like to know if it is possible to see whether each reviewer has recommended acceptance or rejection for the journal.

(0) 讚！ | WuSugai

It's a bit slow, I've been waiting for a long time too.

(0) 讚！ | hhao

2026.8.12 STJ
2026.8.22 WE 2026.8.24 WE
2026.8.31 UR Check on the public account shows 7 invitations sent, 4 invitations accepted, and 1 review completed.

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

Submitted to journal: August 15th
With editor: August 20th
Under review: August 23rd
Require review complete: September 2nd
Rejected: September 3rd (2 revisions, 1 rejection)
The submission process was fast this time, but it was ultimately rejected. It seems like one of the reviewers was quite picky.

(0) 讚！ | 金宝小牛

What state are you in right now?

(0) 讚！ | zqy123

Soon, in less than two months, he was hired.

(0) 讚！ | Zhang7787

Yes, have the holidays started? I see that all the previous comments were posted on the same day and got the WE on the same day. If you're lucky, you'll get UR the next day.

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

We finally sent it out on the 26th after spending 4 days on it.

(0) 讚！ | zqy123

8.26 was finally sent out. It was really slow.

(0) 讚！ | zqy123

Why is it taking so long? I sent it out on the 20th, and today is the 30th and it's still at SJT.

(0) 讚！ | hhao

Has it been a month since we last spoke? I arrived on the 22nd and today is the 24th. The date on our conversation has been updated, I'm not sure if there's a new editor. I saw that it has been a month since we last talked, so I'm feeling balanced.

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

13/07/2026 Submitted to Journal
27/07/2026 With Editor
28/08/2026 With Editor
Is the editor on vacation?

(0) 讚！ | SHUCS

My too
2026.8.12 STJ (regret not choosing edit after seeing comments)
2026.8.22 WE until now

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

Finally, we are in a relationship on 8.22.

(0) 讚！ | zqy123

Submit JMST first, desk reject; Acta, desk reject. Can't wait to try JAC. Details as follows, for research worker brothers and sisters to refer to (big shots and big shot teams don't need to read).
25/06/2026 Submitted to Journal
01/07/2026 With Editor
9/07/2026 Under Review (invited 7, accepted 3 review invitations)
20/07/2026 Under Review (2 reviewers completed reviews)
28/07/2026 RRC
Editor: Major revision, 20 days.
Reviewers: Three major revisions, two very positive, mainly focusing on some details. The third one should be a junior peer, very on point and sharp.
Total of 35 comments, challenging points: request for additional experiments, request for additional tests.
11/08/2026 Article revised
18/08/2026 Under Review
19/08/2026 Article accepted for publication
All three reviewers did not provide additional comments, all suggested Accept.

(0) 讚！ | 我de豪杰物语

Is yours still STJ? I invested in STJ on the 12th.

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

I'm sorry, but there is no text provided for translation.

(0) 讚！ | zzzzzzym

Wait a minute, I also stayed in St. John's for over a week at that time.

(0) 讚！ | WuSugai

Submitted to STJ on 2026.08.12 (No editor selected)
Is it still STJ? Is it slow without selecting an editor, or is everyone on vacation?

(0) 讚！ | xzh1006

Last time it was said that a reviewer completed the review within one day, but later the editor requested major revisions. The two reviewers together provided nearly 20 comments, each requiring citations from nearly 10 articles. One of the reviewers listed references that were almost irrelevant to the content of the article. The revised manuscript was submitted 10 days later and sent for review again 5 days after that. The same reviewer completed the review within one day, and the article was finally accepted. The submission was made on July 9th and accepted on August 15th, taking a total of one and a half months. Overall, the journal was very fast in terms of speed.

(0) 讚！ | Duke321

It's too slow. It's been 7 days since submitted to the journal.

(1) 讚！ | zqy123

Review Complete on 2026.07.08, with 7 review invitations sent in the first round, 2 accepted, but only 1 returned comments. Then on 2026.06.21, 3 more reviewers were invited, 1 accepted, and this reviewer was relatively quick. The feedback provided was for major revisions, but in reality, they were all minor issues.

Submitted revised manuscript on 2026.07.15
Under Review on 2026.07.19
Review Completed on 2026.07.29, with neither of the previous two reviewers making further modification suggestions
Accepted on 2026.08.07

(0) 讚！ | Planck康

I have also submitted it for 20 days, but it has not reached the editor yet.

(0) 讚！ | WHK

Why is this so slow, it's been 20 days since STJ.

(0) 讚！ | Dhjsjsjjsjjj

06/08/2026 still in the hands of the editor.

(0) 讚！ | zzzzzzym