D-24-00619
R020240920sub, 0922WE, 1128WE, 1203UR(4,0,0), 1204UR(4,3,0), 1210UR(4,4,0), 1227UR(4,4,1), 20250105RRC(4,4,2), 0121Reminder, 0122Moderate Revision,
R1 0124ReSub, 0127WE (Dr. Giulio Vignoli), 0224UR(3,0,0), 0225UR(3,1,0), 0226UR(3,2,0), 0409UR(3+3,2,0), 0410UR(3+3,2+1,0), 0520UR(6,3,+1), 0611UR(12,3,1), 0612UR(12,4,2), 0613RRC(12,4,3), 0615UR(12,5,3), 0628RRC(12,5,4), 0705RRC(12,5,5), 0709Moderate Revision,
R20712WE, 0714WE, 0714UR(6,0,0), 0714UR(6,1,1), 0714UR(6,2,1), 0714UR(6,3,1), 0801RRC(6,3,2), 0801UR, 0805Accepted.

(0) 讚！ | 淙淙柔水

I have been rejected by the editor for three and a half months, wasting time, feeling speechless.

(0) 讚！ | WSPP

Can civil engineers also submit articles to this journal?

(0) 讚！ | 奋斗+123

July 11th, received.

(0) 讚！ | Abermethy

How is this for you?

(0) 讚！ | hl888

On June 9th, RRC, the center fixed. Two reviewers ran away, leaving only one reviewer who only made requests for visualizations. In addition, many reviewers were invited, but only one accepted the invitation. After the new reviewer finished reviewing, the editor invited more reviewers, but no one accepted the invitation a week later, so the editor gave it to RRC. The new reviewer acknowledged the contributions in the paper, provided detailed comments on the inaccuracies in the descriptions, and the center fixed it in the end. On June 16th, WE.

(0) 讚！ | Abermethy

Hello, have there been any changes to your status? I submitted my article a week ago and it is still with the editor.

(0) 讚！ | WSPP

This journal is really slow. It's been almost two months and it's still "with editor". Will it ever end? I've sent reminder emails but no one replies. Some people get their papers reviewed so quickly, while others stay "with editor" for months!

(0) 讚！ | Olitan

That day? Anyway, very soon.

(0) 讚！ | Abermethy

May I ask how long the interval was between RRC and the decision to edit the major repair?

(0) 讚！ | hhxxv

March 26 Under Review;
April 4 RRC; major revision
April 17 Submission
April 17 With Editor

(0) 讚！ | Abermethy

20240920 Submitted, 20240922 With Editor, 20241128 With Editor, 20241203 Under review(4,0,0), 20241204 Under review(4,3,0), 20241210 Under review(4,4,0), 20241227 Under review(4,4,1), 20250105 Required Reviews Completed (4,4,2), 20250121 Request for Submission, 20250122 Moderate Revision, APPGEO-D-24-00619R1 20250124 Resubmitted, 20250127 With Editor (Dr Giulio Vignoli), 20250224 Under review(3,0,0), 20250225 Under review(3,1,0), 20250226 Under review(3,2,0)

(0) 讚！ | 淙淙柔水

Is there any progress? I have also encountered a similar situation.

(0) 讚！ | hhxxv

March 6th Under Review;
March 17th Under Review;

(0) 讚！ | Abermethy

May I ask when the proof will be sent after the acceptance of this journal?

(0) 讚！ | amingai

I have also encountered this issue, may I ask how you solved it?

(0) 讚！ | hhxxv

Submitted on March 1, 2025, With Editor.

(0) 讚！ | Abermethy

The editing was done quickly, and the manuscript was accepted after the third round of minor revisions.

(0) 讚！ | 奔跑的鱼

The reviewers were very meticulous and quick in reviewing the manuscript. The outcome was provided in a little over four months.

(0) 讚！ | 心如止水555

The journal is excellent, the reviewers' comments are professional and serious, and they are very helpful for improving the paper.

(0) 讚！ | 奔跑的鱼

I sent an email to withdraw the submission at the beginning of December, and then helped me submit it for review.
On January 5th, RRC(4,4,2).

(0) 讚！ | 淙淙柔水

This journal is extremely slow. It has been "WITH EDITOR" for 2 months. The key is that contacting the editorial department through the system is ineffective. Even withdrawing the submission is impossible. It feels like a huge pitfall of a journal.

(0) 讚！ | top飞仔

20240920 Submitted, 20240922 With Editor, 20241128 With Editor, 20241203 Under review(4,0,0), 20241204 Under review(4,3,0), 20241210 Under review(4,4,0), 20241227 Under review(4,4,1), 20250105 Required Reviews Completed (4,4,2).

(0) 讚！ | 淙淙柔水

This journal is very slow. I want to withdraw my submission, but I have sent two emails and have not received a response. I have not been able to withdraw successfully. Is there any other way to withdraw my submission? Urgent request.

(0) 讚！ | top飞仔

I sent a reminder email, but received a notification that it landed in the "wu ren jian kong" mailbox. What should I do if I continue to send "che gao" emails and they keep ending up in the "wu ren jian kong" mailbox?

(0) 讚！ | 柒柒_柒柒