2025.4.21 accept Thanks to the editors and experts, the efficiency is very high.

(0) 讚！ | 聪明的小吃货

Apr 20, 2025 Under Review 1, 2, 5

(0) 讚！ | Joaqu1n

Apr 11, 2025 STJ
Apr 12, 2025 WE
Apr 15, 2025 Under Review 0, 1, 5
Apr 18, 2025 Under Review 0, 2, 5

(0) 讚！ | Joaqu1n

2025.2.6 submission: Abstract exceeds word limit, editor requests revision
2025.2.8 submission
2025.2.10 under editor review
2025.2.20 under review, invited 14, accepted 3, rejected 2
2025.3.16 Major Revision
2025.3.31 under review, invited 2, accepted 2
Hope for good news.

(0) 讚！ | 聪明的小吃货

The first review process was relatively fast, giving major revisions in about 20 days. After revisions, the first two reviewers finished quickly, but the third one dragged on until after the Chinese New Year. The review comments were all returned on February 12th, and on the 19th it became DIP. Praying for a good result, feeling a bit worried.

(0) 讚！ | 寒江独钓

May I ask how long it took from the initial interview to receiving an offer? When did you apply and when were you hired?

(0) 讚！ | 聪明的小吃货

The editor in charge of handling manuscripts is very responsible. The review process may be extended during Christmas, New Year, and Spring Festival. In the first round of reviews, the editor sent review invitations to 20 people, 8 accepted, and 7 completed the review. However, the editor only provided feedback on 5 reviews, with 3 minor revisions and 2 major revisions. After revisions, the editor sent review invitations to 6 people, 5 accepted, and all 5 completed the review with minor revisions accepted.

(0) 讚！ | 米修D

The review process is not very fast, but the editors are very friendly.

(0) 讚！ | 你是在做梦

Brother, they probably have time off for the year-end holidays and are backed up. My rrc is not responding either.

(0) 讚！ | accept接到手软

2024.12.30 rrc, still rrc now, afraid the situation is not good.

(0) 讚！ | lxjx

1/6 RRC, 1/8 still no movement.

(0) 讚！ | accept接到手软

It should be 8-10 days, under review. 10 sent 2, the editor didn't send much either, I don't know if they went on vacation. Now both have completed the review, rrc status. Still haven't received the editor's email.

(0) 讚！ | accept接到手软

Excuse me, how many days have you been in UR?

(0) 讚！ | ws

Submitted on 21st December 2024, processed on 30th December, no updates as of 3rd January 2025. Will it still be reviewed? Any recent submissions?

(0) 讚！ | ws

My offer is buy 10 get 2 free, but I haven't received any additional free items from the editor. Usually, I will receive up to 3 free items based on past experience. Have they gone for Christmas?

(0) 讚！ | accept接到手软

I submitted my work to 3 experts for review. It is possible that RRC could become UR, either due to conflicting opinions or because the experts' opinions are too superficial, which I have encountered before.

(0) 讚！ | cccc2022

May I ask how many minimum reviewers are required for this journal? Submitted 4, received 2, and after review, it was rejected on the same day.

(0) 讚！ | 洋洋洋

The submission was made on December 3rd, and it has been under review by the editor for about 4 or 5 days. There was one revision with the editor on the 9th. It is still under review by the editor. Any experienced experts know what's going on?

(0) 讚！ | accept接到手软

What makes me angry is that the editor recommended three OA journals to me and said that if I agree to transfer, I can accept the paper without external review. It really disgusts me.

(0) 讚！ | 引路人

The article went through major revisions, minor revisions, and ultimately rejection. Both reviewers for the major revision disappeared, so a third reviewer was assigned for the second round of revisions, who approved my changes and provided minor revisions. After the second round of revisions, three new reviewers were assigned for the third round, and one of them recommended rejection. The editor then made the decision to reject the article. Many of the criticisms from the reviewer who recommended rejection were not professional, such as "I mention processing 80 plant samples at once, but the reviewer believes it is unrealistic." The majority of the unprofessional criticisms were along those lines. The rejection letter from editor Gayatri Bakshi stated, "The reviewer advised against publishing your paper in this journal and hence I have no option but to reject it." I am considering appealing this decision, although I doubt it will be successful. It is truly frustrating.

(0) 讚！ | 引路人

The revised submission has been successfully accepted after the major revisions. It may be that the foreign editor processes manuscripts at a relatively slower pace.

(0) 讚！ | s835074144

The editor is responsible and diligent, with a fast turnaround time for processing manuscripts. The submission deadline was delayed once due to the National Day holiday. 
2024.08.25 submit
2024.08.27 with editor
2024.08.27 under review
2024.09.14 major revision
2024.10.31 under review
2024.11.08 major revision
2024.11.25 with editor
2024.11.25 under review
2024.11.25 minor revision
2024.12.06 with editor
2024.12.06 accept

(0) 讚！ | fischermann

The overall submission process went relatively smoothly, although there were a lot of revisions.

2024.4.25: Submitted PDF
2024.4.29: In contact with editor
2024.4.29: Under review
2024.5.14: Under review
2024.6.08: Major revision (6.29)
2024.6.28: Under review
2024.7.17: Minor revision (7.31)
2024.7.19: With editor
2024.7.20: Under review
2024.8.9: Major revision (8.23+7)
2024.8.30: With editor
2024.9.4: Under review
2024.9.15: Minor revision
2024.9.20: With editor
2024.9.23: Accepted

(0) 讚！ | 欧阳尚韬

The above information was filled in randomly.
The review process is not double-blind, and authors are required to return within 14 days after accepting the review.

(0) 讚！ | 爱吃煎饼

How are things going now? Has it been submitted for review?

(0) 讚！ | 张12