2025.4.29 Submitted
2025.5.01 Under Review
2025.5.23 Revision
2025.6.5  Under Review
2025.6.11 Revision
2025.6.16 with editor
2025.6.18 Accepted

The review process was relatively fast, but the reviewers requested too many citations. They would give a major revision if citations were not included, even though the relevance of the citations was minimal. The first revision did not include all the citations, leading to a second revision. The editor did not take any action on this issue.

(0) 讚！ | 星辰

May I ask if the corresponding author's email received an email requesting format revisions after submitting the manuscript?

(0) 讚！ | Chuanjia Zhao

On 2025/1/22, the decision is still in process. It has been almost a month since the editor received the reviewers' comments, but no decision has been made yet. An email was sent to David Joseph, but no response has been received. It is really slow and tests one's patience greatly.

(0) 讚！ | 小葡萄爱吃甜草莓

The revised version has been submitted for over a month, the reviewers have completed the second review, and it has been stuck at "Decision in Process" for nearly 20 days. Despite sending a reminder email, there has been no response. The paper was submitted on August 2, 2024, and it has been almost half a year now without a decision. Frustrated with the journal.

(0) 讚！ | 小葡萄爱吃甜草莓

How did it end? How long did you wait?

(0) 讚！ | Accept吧啊

From summer to winter, there has been no news yet. The review comments have been received long ago, but the editor has not made a decision. I have sent four reminder emails, but there has been no response. I feel like a powerless research pony.

(0) 讚！ | 小葡萄爱吃甜草莓

Decision in Process 10/30/2024
It has been over a month now, and the editor has yet to provide feedback on the review and final decision. I have sent reminder emails four times, but each response is almost the same. It has been dragging on. This is my first time submitting to this journal, and the experience has been extremely poor. The submission process is too long, and I do not recommend choosing this journal.

(0) 讚！ | 小葡萄爱吃甜草莓

08/01/2024
10/30/2024 Decision in Process
11/21/2024 Decision in Process
Two reminders sent in between, but still no response. Has anyone encountered this situation before?

(0) 讚！ | 小葡萄爱吃甜草莓

09/26/2024 Required reviews have been completed. The reviewers have submitted their opinions, but the editors have yet to make a final decision after two weeks. It feels like the paper may not be accepted.

(0) 讚！ | 撒盐少女

08/01/2024 submitted
09/12/2024 under review
The track page shows invitations to multiple reviewers, 2+ have agreed to review, 0 reviews have been completed.
Anxiously awaiting review comments.

(0) 讚！ | 撒盐少女

You can send an email to inquire.

(0) 讚！ | greap tree

10.8 submitted to editor
10.17 with editor
10.29 Under Review
11.17 Required Reviews Completed 
11.20 Revise
12.14 Date submission began
12.16 under review
12.20 required reviewers completed
12.21 accepted

10.8 submitted to editor
10.17 with editor
10.29 Under Review
11.17 Required Reviews Completed 
11.20 Revise
12.14 Date submission began
12.16 under review
12.20 required reviewers completed
12.21 accepted

(0) 讚！ | lkcsu

Submit: 10.8
Required Reviews Completed: 11.17

Translation:
Submit: October 8th
Required Reviews Completed: November 17th

(0) 讚！ | lkcsu

Trashy journal, transferred from ACS, it has been "Submitted to Editorial Office" for over 20 days. After sending two reminders, it finally moved to the "with editor" status. However, it has been another half month without being sent for review and got rejected without any explanation. Speechless. Will never submit to this journal again.

(1) 讚！ | LYH不要996

Submission in February
Submission to the journal in April
Assignment to an editor in May
Review in June
Receive feedback in July
Acceptance in August
Thank you to the editor and hope the journal continues to improve. Also, I hope all the friends who submitted can succeed.

(0) 讚！ | 最后一只仓鼠

It took a full two months to reach the editor's hands.

(0) 讚！ | 凯

I have been submitting for two months and it has not reached the editor's hands yet.

(1) 讚！ | 凯

It has been nearly a month since submission, and it has not yet reached the hands of the editor.

(2) 讚！ | missouton

Has your article reached the editor's hands? How long do I have to wait?

(0) 讚！ | missouton

It's been three weeks since I submitted it, and it still hasn't reached the editor's hands. Isn't there anyone working to take care of this journal?

(2) 讚！ | 最后一只仓鼠

Hey bro, may I ask how to withdraw a submission?

(0) 讚！ | An apple a day

The manuscript has been withdrawn before it was even processed...

(32) 讚！ | 李万里

It has been two weeks since I submitted, but no one is taking care of the journal.

(0) 讚！ | 李万里

Is there any news, bro? It's been a week and it's still being delivered.

(0) 讚！ | SuperXin666

How long does it typically take for a manuscript to go from "submit" to "with editor" recently? It has been one week already.

(2) 讚！ | lyxlyx