Submitted on January 19
Under review on January 23
Received first reviewer's comments on February 3
Second reviewer agreed to review on February 5
Received major revisions with a two-month deadline on February 17
Returned on April 15
Accepted on April 24
Overall, the review process was very efficient, but I took a bit longer to make the revisions myself.

(0) 讚！ | 平安树的小树苗

Bragging!! Accept the modification directly!! Accept accept accept!! Hired hired hired!!

(0) 讚！ | toppp

Forgot to mention that it is "Under Review", and it has only been a couple of days since "With Editor".

(0) 讚！ | Y3B058

25.5.8 Submitted to Journal
25.5.9 With Editor
25.5.19 Minor Revision
25.5.25 With Editor (Revise Submission)
25.5.26 Accept

Compared to Chinese journals, this efficiency is simply off the charts! Thank you to the reviewers, thank you to the editor.

(5) 讚！ | Y3B058

This journal is produced by everyone in just a few days.

(0) 讚！ | 996LWT

3.6 submit to journal
3.12 under review
4.3 major revision, 14 comments from 2 reviewers
4.21 r1
4.23 under review
4.25 minor revision, 1 comment from 1 reviewer
4.26 r2
5.4 Accept
The entire review process was very efficient, and the suggestions provided by the reviewers were constructive. Best wishes for the continued success of the journal!

(0) 讚！ | 谷雨。

2025.1.24 sub
2025.1.28 we
2025.2.12 ur
2025.2.23 rrc
2025.3.11 major
2025.4.30 resub
2025.5.4 accept

The first SCI paper in the first year of graduate school, which is a review article. I submitted it without being invited, and initially there were many issues. The reviewers were gentle but raised 6+12 sharp questions. Probably because they saw I was a beginner, they didn't reject it outright. 

I spent two months rewriting the entire article and responded to over a dozen comments. After revisions, the editor accepted it directly. Overall, the process was quite fast, similar to the speed of the official website. The editor was also quite diligent, and I was fortunate to encounter kind reviewers. I also appreciate myself for staying up late every night for the past two months to make revisions.

(0) 讚！ | yicheng.pan

Accepted without any modifications.

(0) 讚！ | 姚蕴恒

Accepted without any modifications.

(0) 讚！ | 姚蕴恒

Given a few months for editing.

(0) 讚！ | 996LWT

I want to know how many months of repair time my family members have given, I have given two months.

(0) 讚！ | 996LWT

2025.2.15 submitted
2025.2.17 with editor
2025.2.18 under review
2025.3.22 accepted
Two reviewers for the first round of review. The result of the first reviewer's comments was "Congratulations! Excellent work." The second reviewer's comments were not yet received when the editor decided to accept the paper based on the first reviewer's comments.
2025.3.24 online
The editor was very efficient, taking only 40 days from submission to acceptance. Done!

(0) 讚！ | 姚蕴恒

It's been three weeks, not two weeks.

(0) 讚！ | 花生多糖

Feb. 18 submitted
Feb. 19 with editor
Mar. 13 Reject
Dragged in the editor's hands for 2 weeks, directly rejected, saying there is no novelty, too many manuscripts, the editor is Fabiana Arduini. This is not a reason, I did in situ characterization + theoretical calculation + actual samples. I don't know what the reason is, are all journals so arrogant now?

(0) 讚！ | 花生多糖

ACA transferred over in October 24th.
After two months of review, six reviewers made major revisions with a total of 80 questions, but most of them were easily addressed. It took three weeks to supplement data and revise the article.
One month later, minor revisions were made. Five reviewers agreed to accept the paper, while one reviewer raised some formatting issues that were addressed and resubmitted.
Thinking that the paper would be accepted directly, it was sent for review again, leaving us speechless.
It is important to be cautious when rushing the publication of an article!

(0) 讚！ | 1000pieces

Hello, may I ask how long after you transferred did you submit for approval? I am currently at this step as well, waiting.

(0) 讚！ | SAIJINWANG

How long does it usually take for the first RRC result to come out?

(0) 讚！ | 咘咘咘咘

The first trial has been delayed for 5 months, causing anxiety for those eager to graduate.

(0) 讚！ | 麦子语

Submitted a manuscript on 3-17-2024, which remained under review. Withdrawn on 11-15 and submitted to MCA on 11-17. Accepted on 1-09-2025. In the withdrawal letter, it was mentioned that the journal may not be considered in the future.

(0) 讚！ | JNUfeng

After being rejected by ACA, the submission was quickly resubmitted to another journal, which had a fast and efficient editorial process.

(0) 讚！ | 冬飞离

10.16 ACA transferred to MJ
10.17 under review invited 12 accept 2
11.01 review complete
11.01 major revision accepted, one reviewer explicitly stated lack of innovation, not suitable for publication in MJ, need to add experimental data
12.08 revision submitted, grateful for the major revision provided by the editor, made very serious modifications, reviewed a lot of literature, provided literature support for the issues raised by the rejecting reviewer, overall it was like writing a new paper.
12.09 under review invited 2 accept 1
12.24 under review, one feedback received, probably triggered by the Christmas holiday deadline
01.03 accept
Directly accepted, only after reading the feedback did I realize it was a second review by the rejecting reviewer, who mentioned that although the paper still lacked innovation, the logical flow of the paper eliminated his confusion, and the writing content made him consider it a very good paper, worthy of publication. I was truly excited to see this, knowing that my diligent and careful revisions finally moved the reviewer who wanted to reject my paper, and received full recognition. Thank you to the reviewers and the editor.

(1) 讚！ | bumeng

Submitted on 11.04, revised on 11.25, resubmitted on 12.16, and accepted on 12.24.

(0) 讚！ | fafafafa!

I made an appointment with the editor on the 11th, but the time changed on the 13th, and there has been no progress so far.

(0) 讚！ | 咘咘咘咘

These days have been quiet, I guess there's a chance Christmas has passed.

(0) 讚！ | cat#@

The submission I made on December 9th is only under review in the past two days. It's a bit slow, but we'll have to wait.

(0) 讚！ | 左右不为难