At the end of May, the submission status changed to "with editor" after 2 days. There was no change for the next 14 days, so I sent an email to follow up. The next day, it changed to "under review". As of now, it is 5-2-0, but it has been almost 20 days since the first reviewer accepted the invitation and has not reviewed it yet. Have they disappeared?

(0) 讚！ | 所有文章皆Accept

Submit in mid-October 2025
Receive major revision comments in mid-January 2026
Receive the manuscript back in early February 2025
Accept in early June 2026

(0) 讚！ | 捍哈

I want to ask what format the first draft should be in. It seems like there are no specific requirements on the official website.

(2) 讚！ | water

I also want to ask.

(0) 讚！ | water

3.5 submission, 3.26 rejection. Only one reviewer was invited in total, but feedback was received from two reviewers. The second reviewer's feedback even partially echoed the first reviewer's feedback. I seriously doubt the editor even wanted to accept the submission in the first place. Why bother reviewing it? Just reject it and save time.

(0) 讚！ | 11

Please translate the following paragraph into English: Accept

(0) 讚！ | Eternal

The second revision has been sent back for 25 days and is still in the hands of the editor.

(0) 讚！ | Eternal

Reviewed by one AI reviewer, criticized by one reviewer for nitpicking, and only one reviewer carefully read it.

(0) 讚！ | 11

Submitted on July 21, 2025
Under review on July 23, 2025, inviting 3 reviewers
1 reviewer accepted the invitation on July 29, 2025
1 reviewer completed the review on August 11, 2025
Added 1 more reviewer on August 12, 2025
Added another reviewer on September 20, 2025
1 reviewer agreed to review on September 22, 2025
Another reviewer agreed to review on September 25, 2025
Another reviewer completed the review on September 28, 2025, RRC
Rejected on October 4, 2025

(0) 讚！ | 11

Second review, yesterday the number of Review invitations accepted was 1; today it has changed to Review invitations accepted: 0. Did the reviewer run away?

(0) 讚！ | Eternal

25.3.18 Submitted
25.3.19 With Editor
25.3.22 Under Review/9 revisions-1 acceptance
25.3.25 9 revisions-5 acceptance
25.4.12 Required Review Complete
25.4.21 Decision in Process
25.4.23 Major revise (limited to 25.5.13)
25.4.29 Submitted revised manuscript
25.5.06 Required Review Complete
25.5.17 Decision in Process
25.5.19 Accept

The time from Required Review Complete to Decision in Process is a bit long, with both instances being almost ten days apart.

(0) 讚！ | lagrange cauchy

04.22 With Editor
Found a reviewer on 4.30, found another reviewer on 6.10, and found a third reviewer on 6.17.
The first reviewer has not yet provided feedback.
A bit slow.

(0) 讚！ | Eternal

Is this a direct submission to the journal? Or is it a conference proceeding being submitted to the journal?

(0) 讚！ | 叶尼塞河到不了阿拉善

What's going on, buddy? Did they reject us after just two days of external audit?

(0) 讚！ | afhiujsdbuiafsb

Send notification within two days, highlighting speed and good feedback.

(0) 讚！ | zzs

2024.03.19: Submission
2024.05.03: Minor revisions, two reviewers, three weeks to respond to reviewer comments
2024.05.23: Resubmit revised manuscript
2024.06.11: Acceptance

(0) 讚！ | YuGF

I searched for a reviewer for a long time, and it took more than three months to receive major revisions after submission. After revising, I waited for more than two months to be accepted, and had to send emails to urge the process. Both submission and revisions were updated promptly after urging, indicating that the editor reviewed them personally

(1) 讚！ | LEEG

Hello, do you have an email address?

(0) 讚！ | DASHAN739111

Complain about the editorial department. They often forget to review and update, and without reminding them, they won't update the progress. Finally, they accepted the submission before Christmas

(0) 讚！ | chrono_w

2023.3.3 submitted to journal
2023.4.18 required reviews completed
2023.5.1 major revision
2023.6.5 resubmitted
2023.9.6 waited too long and sent a letter urging the manuscript
2023.9.25 decision in process
2023.9.26 minor revision
2023.10.20 resubmitted
2023.11.8 decision in process
2023.11.21 minor revision
2023.11.23 resubmitted
2023.12.18 waited too long and sent another letter urging the manuscript
2023.12.19 decision in process
2023.12.20 accept

可靠性领域不错的期刊，安排了两名审稿人，但可能各自的细分方向不同，猜测可能一位偏工艺器件方向，一位偏系统方向，都在各自关心的方面提了很多问题和建议，对提升论文质量帮助很大

(2) 讚！ | chrono_w

Submitted at the beginning of November, under review since the 5th

(0) 讚！ | qlwym

Please translate the following passage into English and Japanese, and title them respectively: 9.1 submmit

(0) 讚！ | wjh1997

10-18 submmit
10-21 under review
11-3 under review
The last review status remained at 10.25.
Still anxiously waiting, unsure how long the first review will take.

(0) 讚！ | cheese1996

Hello, may I ask what template you are using for submitting to this journal? I noticed that the homepage does not have many requirements for the formatting template.

(0) 讚！ | 一路绿灯

2021.07.27 submitted to journal
2021.08.01 with editor
2021.08.02 under review
2021.08.08 under review
2021.08.11 under review
2021.08.28 decision in process
2021.08.30 revise
2021.09.29 resubmitted
2021.09.29 with editor
2021.10.01 under review
2021.10.16 under review
2021.10.29 under review
2021.11.23 decision in process
2021.11.25 minor
2021.12.23 resubmitted
2021.12.24 with editor
2022.01.04 under review
2022.01.06 Required Reviews Completed
2022.01.08 Decision in Process
2022.01.11 Accept

Translation:
2021.07.27 submitted to journal
2021.08.01 with editor
2021.08.02 under review
2021.08.08 under review
2021.08.11 under review
2021.08.28 decision in process
2021.08.30 revise
2021.09.29 resubmitted
2021.09.29 with editor
2021.10.01 under review
2021.10.16 under review
2021.10.29 under review
2021.11.23 decision in process
2021.11.25 minor
2021.12.23 resubmitted
2021.12.24 with editor
2022.01.04 under review
2022.01.06 Required Reviews Completed
2022.01.08 Decision in Process
2022.01.11 Accept

(0) 讚！ | 吟梦潇湘