20251007 submission
20251008 peer review
20251027 revision report
20260112 resubmit revision
20260130 accepted
20260227 publish online

请翻译为：

20251007 submission
20251008 peer review
20251027 revision report
20260112 resubmit revision
20260130 accepted
20260227 publish online

(0) 讚！ | bobcf

After submission, the manuscript was sent for review the next day. 20 days later, feedback was received from three reviewers, one positive, one neutral, and one in agreement for publication. After the reply, it was accepted 20 days later and immediately published online after proof submission, which was quite fast. Although there are other journals with higher impact factors, the reputation of PRB in physics is still very good.

(0) 讚！ | bobcf

Is there any requirement for the email address when registering for this journal? I have tried registering with several different email addresses and it keeps saying the email is invalid.

(0) 讚！ | MC idol

Submission will be reviewed and replied within three days, and accepted articles will be returned within a week, the process is very fast. The editor also suggests to make appropriate modifications to the title.

(0) 讚！ | bisonghu

Directly killed within two days, so decisive...

(0) 讚！ | 村中城

Dear viewers, I have another small question: do the editors of PRB work on weekends? Considering the large volume of submissions received by PRB...

(0) 讚！ | 村中城

For the first time in my life, I submitted a paper to PRB, directly refuting a classic theory that is still widely accepted in PRB and other journals. Am I asking for trouble? If what I have proposed is considered original, I have heard that it is difficult to avoid rejection when submitting to reputable journals.

(0) 讚！ | 村中城

Can I ask you experts what are the requirements of PRB for the graph? What format of file? Of course, it is about schematic diagram, not data graph.

(0) 讚！ | 村中城

2025-04-01 WE, half a month, hope to submit for review.

(0) 讚！ | ...111...

Submission on March 17, 2025.
It's been almost ten days since it was with the editors on March 24, 2020. Is it taking so long?

(0) 讚！ | ...111...

This comment really amused me. PRB publishes 5000 articles a year, do you think they are all at the level of Wen Xiaogang? There are also many that are not very good.

(0) 讚！ | Curry

The articles in PRB are of really high quality, although the content may not be the most current, the depth is even deeper than PRL. People who can publish in PRB must have exceptional theoretical foundations. It's unbelievable that such a good journal has been classified as a 2nd tier by the Chinese Academy of Sciences... You just know how ridiculous their classification system is... And then there's JMST, always sticking to the top tier... Anyone can see which journal has higher quality.

(0) 讚！ | Saguenay

The review process is really slow, but the editing process is quite fast. It took 3 months to receive the review comments for the first submission because the reviewer couldn't be found. Fortunately, the comments were positive and the paper was accepted after two rounds of revisions. In total, it took almost 6 months from submission to acceptance.

(0) 讚！ | 906

Key time points in the submission process can be referenced as follows:
Received: 13Nov2023 (first submission of initial draft, assigned to reviewers 3 days later)
Decision: 22Dec2023 (received comments from two reviewers, minor revisions)
Revised: 18Feb2024 (revised and resubmitted)
Accepted: 25Mar2024 (editor sought a third reviewer, who agreed and accepted

(0) 讚！ | 磕颜

12.18 submitted
1.2 under review
2.16 major revise (One reviewer completely rejected our work, another gave minor revisions, the editor added a third reviewer who also requested minor revisions)
3.29 reject (After revisions, the reviewer who completely rejected the work maintained their original stance, and the editor rejected the manuscript outright)
The journal process was fast, but unfortunately we encountered a reviewer who completely rejected our work

(1) 讚！ | 宁缺毋滥.

How long will it take to see results after the rework?

(1) 讚！ | 磕颜

Can I take a look at your article? I also work in the field of phonon heat transfer and just submitted an article to PRB

(0) 讚！ | 宁缺毋滥.

Discharge from hospital

(0) 讚！ | xxyh

You should have him submit the article to prb instead of prl, so that there will be one prb publication per year

(3) 讚！ | 齐心

Submitting papers for ultrafast physics, they were reviewed within two days. The editorial processing speed was even faster than the speed of Draven's bloodthirst, but the review speed was slower than my grandmother's running speed. The two reviewers at Physical Review B have a commendable position in the field of condensed matter, and their reviews are quite professional. In fact, there is no need to be afraid of submitting to this journal as long as your work is well-founded and includes some reasonable physical explanations

(14) 讚！ | jigglyboy

A while ago, I got my first PRB in my life and I hope it's not the last one. There were three reviewers in total. Reviewers 1 and 2 had no major revisions and both thought it was acceptable. However, Reviewer 3 gave me the impression that they had heard of my research field and were somewhat interested, but their literature review was stuck at least 30 years ago. They were almost oblivious to some important work in my field from the 1990s and early this century. They kept getting tangled up in a point that had been recognized as not a problem in this field nearly 20 years ago, and it took several rounds of back and forth before begrudgingly accepting my manuscript. Nonetheless, the fact that the manuscript was approved is good, and I thank the editor for their keen insight

(0) 讚！ | Automata

Dear, I suggest you use your own account here.

(0) 讚！ | Bolanster

When submitting a manuscript, may I ask how to designate the supervisor as the corresponding author using my own account? Or can I only submit the manuscript using the supervisor's account?

(0) 讚！ | suvar

PRB does not need a template, just submit directly.

(0) 讚！ | 志在远方

A new partition has been created, and many Qiansheng have been promoted to District 1, while PRB remains firmly in District 2.

(2) 讚！ | will@gf