This status indicates that the requirement of having at least two reviewers complete the review has been met. It will be determined whether there will be any additional external reviewers submitting their opinions. If not, the editor will provide the next steps of major revisions, minor revisions, etc. based on the current opinions of the external reviewers.

(0) 讚！ | HHLY.

The submission was made on September 23, 2026, and the initial review was completed on September 26. Two reviewers finished their assessments on October 8, and the system then displayed "Required Reviews Completed." Does the appearance of "Required Reviews Completed" mean that the manuscript will be rejected?

(0) 讚！ | 科研小趴菜成长中

Hello, may I ask how many external audit experts' opinions were taken into account in the recent revision?

(0) 讚！ | HHLY.

Hello, may I ask how many external audit experts were hired recently to review this major revision?

(0) 讚！ | HHLY.

2026.08.25 submit
2026.08.26 with editor
2026.09.06 with editor
2026.09.06 under Review
2026.09.19 major revision
2026.09.26 with editor
2026.09.28 under Review
2026.10.03 RRC
2026.10.05 accept

The third paper of the year was submitted and processed efficiently. We hope the journal continues to improve! The handling editor is L-S.Fan.

(0) 讚！ | 夜枫之舞

8/6    STJ
8/12  under review
8/24  major revision
9/6    with editor
9/8    under review
9/12  RRC
9/14  Accept
Thank you to the editor and reviewers. The reviewers were very professional and their questions greatly improved the quality of the manuscript. The editor handled everything very promptly.

(0) 讚！ | taoxiaoyao

2026.06.18 Submit
2026.06.23 With Editor
2026.06.23 Under Review
2026.06.25 Under Review
2026.08.02 Major Revision
2026.08.16 With Editor
2026.08.17 Under Review
2026.09.04 RRC
2026.09.06 accept

First submission, quite lucky, the manuscript was processed very promptly -,-
Thanks to Professor Yu for timely handling and the professional reviewers, wishing the journal better and better!

(0) 讚！ | zhimn

Handled by L.S. Fan indeed.

(0) 讚！ | 夜枫之舞

Indeed, L.S. Fan.

(0) 讚！ | 夜枫之舞

Submitted to Journal-2026.08.25
Reviewed by Editor-2026.08.26
Reviewed by Editor-2026.09.06
Under Review-2026.09.06
3 submitted, 2 under review, 0 accepted.

(0) 讚！ | 夜枫之舞

Excuse me, is Wu the editor? Chuan-yu really processes manuscripts quickly.

(0) 讚！ | vlk

With the editor for half a month, I guess it's Fan who is doing the editing, and it's slow.

(0) 讚！ | vlk

2026.08.25 submit
2026.08.26 with editor
Waiting...

(0) 讚！ | 夜枫之舞

2026.06.25 submit
2026.06.26 with editor
2026.06.29 with editor
2026.06.30 under Review
2026.07.08 minor revision
2026.07.10 with editor
2026.07.13 under Review
2026.07.15 RRC
2026.07.16 accept

(0) 讚！ | 夜枫之舞

Which direction did Fan Academy choose? I think I was a fan Academy once before, but it was super slow, no matter how much I urged. I remember the other editors were quite fast, Wu editor was super fast.

(0) 讚！ | vlk

Has Academician Fan L-S recently handled the paper? It has been 20 days since the second review by RRC, and they are not responding to emails. Is there an editor who is Fan L-S's brother?

(0) 讚！ | Qiuyuchao

Bro, how are you doing? Has Academician Fan dealt with your issue? How long has it been processed? It's been ten days for me and there's been no change at all.

(0) 讚！ | Qiuyuchao

Congratulations, borrowing some good luck.

(0) 讚！ | zhimn

Approximately how long will it take to produce results? It arrived in the editor's hands on July 14th.

(0) 讚！ |

I submitted it for review in three or four days at that time, and it felt okay. I don't know why it's taking so long in the hands of the reviewers.

(0) 讚！ | zhimn

How long does it usually take to be reviewed? I submitted it last Tuesday.

(0) 讚！ |