Submission received 24 Oct 2025
Editor assigned 29 Oct 2025
First reviewer(s) invited 30 Oct 2025
Reviewer report(s) received 20 Nov 2025
Revision requested 12 Dec 2025
Revision received 09 Feb 2026
Submission accepted 20 Feb 2026

(0) 讚！ | CSYWM

Hello, friend, I would like to ask if there is a fee for publishing this journal.

(0) 讚！ | Accept**

I had to rush to submit the manuscript once, and now I have been constantly inviting reviewers. I don't know what to do next.

(0) 讚！ | YUYU1307

Submission received 30 Sep 2025
Editor assigned 01 Oct 2025
First reviewer(s) invited 25 Oct 2025

(1) 讚！ | YUYU1307

How are you doing now, may I ask?

(0) 讚！ | Haili Dong

Ready for editorial assignment on July 17, 2025
Editor assigned on July 17, 2025
Peer review on August 6, 2025

(0) 讚！ | fenyyy

Submission received 17 Jul 2025
Submission is under technical check 17 Jul 2025
Submission passed technical check 17 Jul 2025

(1) 讚！ | fenyyy

It's been two months and 6 days, still with editor. I'm kind of dying.

(0) 讚！ | hxxhxx

2025.4.15 Submitted
2025.4.17 Under review by editor
2025.4.30 Editor invites reviewers, and 4 reviewers accept the invitation on the same day
2025.6.8 Received review comments, major revisions, feedback from 3 reviewers
2025.7.5 Revised
2025.7.7 Editor invites the previous 3 reviewers, all accept on the same day
2025.7.9 Accepted
The reviewers' comments are very constructive, although some may be sharp, responding and explaining well can greatly improve the acceptance rate.

(0) 讚！ | gopsel

I am also one of them. It took me over half a month to submit before the editor invited reviewers.

(0) 讚！ | Accept**

I submitted to this journal for the first time and felt that the overall speed was slow. I wonder if it is because of the large number of submissions this year that the editors are unable to keep up. I submitted on April 15, 2025, and was invited to review on April 30. Four reviewers accepted the invitation on the same day, but as of June 2, only two reviewers have provided feedback. I hope to receive feedback from the other two reviewers as soon as possible.

(0) 讚！ | gopsel

Encountered a divine editor, the speed of each stage is particularly fast! The quality of the journal is also very high, hoping the impact factor will rise quickly!
Three reviewers were invited in total.
Submission received 27 Dec 2024
Editor assigned 29 Dec 2024
First reviewer(s) invited 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer(s) accepted 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer report(s) received 13 Jan 2025
Revision requested 10 Feb 2025
Revision received 08 Mar 2025
First reviewer(s) invited 09 Mar 2025
Reviewer report(s) received 13 Mar 2025
Submission accepted 25 Apr 2025

(1) 讚！ | 一口大橘

Submitted on July 25, 2024, received first feedback on September 22, 2024, first revised submission on October 20, 2024, received second feedback on November 7, 2024, submitted on November 26, 2024, directly accepted on November 27, 2024, published on January 9, taking 5 months in total. The journal editors are very efficient and responsive, hoping for a quick increase in the impact factor!

(0) 讚！ | haodachu

Submission received 22 Jul 2024
Editor assigned 22 Jul 2024
First reviewer(s) invited 29 Jul 2024
Reviewer(s) accepted 30 Jul 2024
Reviewer report(s) received 19 Aug 2024
Revision requested 26 Aug 2024
Revision received 03 Sep 2024
First reviewer(s) invited 09 Sep 2024
Reviewer(s) accepted 10 Sep 2024
Reviewer report(s) received 13 Sep 2024
Submission accepted 25 Oct 2024
Publishing and rights complete 13 Dec 2024

(0) 讚！ | 一路向北1168

The review process was relatively slow, possibly due to difficulty in finding reviewers. The second reviewer delayed the process for over two months. The manuscript was submitted on May 2, 2024, first revised on October 17, second revised on November 3, and finally accepted on November 28. During the second revision, changes were also made to the corresponding author.

(0) 讚！ | lxk123

I feel that the third district is the most reasonable, the Chinese Academy of Sciences' reduction zone is like playing.

(0) 讚！ | 阿hao1

25 Mar 2024 submitted (IF=3.4[2022]) (2.8 [2023])
06 Apr Reviewers invited
28 Apr Reviews received
20 Jun Reviews received
22 Jun Revision requested R1 (Major)
19 Aug Reviews received
20 Aug Revision requested (R2) Minor
05 Sep (R2) Submitted
09 Sep Reviewers invited (for R3)
18 Sep Reviews received
26 Sep Reviewers agreed
04 Oct Reviews received
13 Oct Revision requested (R3)[Minor)
14 Oct (R3) submitted

15 Oct 2024 ACCEPTED Alhamdulillah

(0) 讚！ | Ali YEMEN

There's no way this journal should be classified into Zone 4, right?

(0) 讚！ | aaa

The journal has a long history and I will consider submitting again after three months

(0) 讚！ | 阿hao1

Have you sent it for external review?

(0) 讚！ | 阿hao1

Submitted in May 2017, never peer reviewed, rejected in September 2018, editor sent an email suggesting resubmission, which is ridiculous. Resubmit what, if being fooled by you once is your fault, being fooled by you twice is my fault

(0) 讚！ | 老帅哥

Hello, may I know how many reviewers you are?

(0) 讚！ | 阿hao1

How many reviewers are there?

(0) 讚！ | 阿hao1

Submission history
23 Nov 2023
Submission is in publishing and rights
23 Nov 2023
Peer review
Submission status	Date
Submission accepted
20 Nov 2023
Submission under peer review
14 Nov 2023
Submission passed technical check
14 Nov 2023 Amendment received
14 Nov 2023 Revision received
18 Jul 2023 Submission received

(1) 讚！ | 仙林以东

"Receive for 3 and a half months."

(0) 讚！ | chenchao718