26.09.19 Revision Submit R4
26.09.20 WE
26.09.20 UR 0/0/1
26.09.29 RRC 1/1/1
26.10.04 Revise (True·Minor 14 days), messed up
26.10.05 Revision Submit R5
26.10.06 WE
26.10.07 Accept, surprised, thought it would need another review
Overall evaluation: 5 rounds of revisions. The reviewers were extremely meticulous and paid great attention to detail. However, they were not deliberately difficult and raised objective issues, even though some were new. The editor must be praised for handling the manuscript very quickly. Despite going through multiple rounds of revisions, each handling was very prompt, and the total time for 5 revisions was only 4 months. Thanks to Professor Kazuhide Ito for his editing.

(0) 讚！ | H.H.

The most rounds of peer review broke once
26.06.05 Submission
26.06.05 WE
26.06.07 UR 0/0/5
26.06.30 RRC 2/2/5
26.06.30 Revise (Major 21 days)
26.07.14 Revision Submit R1, as stable as an old dog
26.07.15 WE
26.07.15 UR 0/0/2
26.07.29 RRC 2/2/2
26.07.29 Revise (Major 14 days)
26.08.07 Revision Submit R2, feeling a bit nervous
26.08.09 WE
26.08.09 UR 0/0/1
26.08.30 RRC 1/1/1
26.08.31 Revise (Major 14 days)
26.09.05 Revision Submit R3, feeling a bit frustrated
26.09.06 WE
26.09.07 UR 0/0/1
26.09.18 RRC 1/1/1
26.09.18 Revise (Minor 14 days), laughing out loud

(0) 讚！ | H.H.

This is the second time I have published a paper in this journal this year, and it was another lightning speed experience!! The timeline was: submitted on July 13th, under review on July 24th (invited by 17 reviewers, 6 accepted), review completed on September 1st with 21 days for revisions (5 reviewers suggested major revisions, 1 suggested minor revisions), revised on September 16th, and accepted on September 25th.

(0) 讚！ | StacyDong

2026.9.9 Submission
2026.9.10 WE
2026.9.16 No news

(0) 讚！ | uiuu

September 12, 2026 sbj
September 12, 2026 we
September 13, 2026 ur 0/0/4

(0) 讚！ | Pinkmanvv

Excuse me, my second review is also 2/2/1 now, it has been going on for a week. Will the editor keep waiting for that reviewer? Has your article been reviewed by the second reviewer and entered RC, or did the editor not wait and proceed directly?

(0) 讚！ | chliang

Thank you for your response!

(0) 讚！ | 马勒隔壁斯基

The editor is Athanasios Tzempelikos, PhD.

(0) 讚！ | lvmazha

How long did the final approval take?

(0) 讚！ | 夕1

6.19 under review
6.29 17/2/0

(0) 讚！ | chliang

Do you have any friends who have submitted articles on the ventilation direction of tunnels? Does this journal include articles on this topic? There are articles on this topic in the literature of this journal, but a previous submission was rejected by the editor, stating that it did not fit within the scope.

(0) 讚！ | HHLY.

May I ask which editor you are?

(0) 讚！ | 马勒隔壁斯基

6.9我们

(0) 讚！ | chliang

0610 UR

(0) 讚！ | wang

6.9 stj

(0) 讚！ | chliang

The first paper, BAE, shares a timeline as follows:
03/28 Submitted
04/04 Under Review, sent to 11 reviewers
04/09 Received 1, completed 1
05/02 Completed 2 revisions based on reviewer comments
05/02 Revised based on 24 comments from two reviewers
05/14 Submitted revised manuscript + cover letter
05/16 Under Review
05/17 Received 2, completed 1
06/09 Reviewer's comments addressed and accepted
The editor handling the manuscript is Taehoon Hong. His team recently published a similar study, and our paper has some conflicting academic views with theirs. However, Editor Hong is very objective and allows for different opinions to be presented. He is also very efficient, receiving positive feedback!

(0) 讚！ | 潇洒_

June 3, 2026 STJ
June 4, 2026 WE

(0) 讚！ | wang

Submission: May 6, 2026, with editor
Waiting in progress

(0) 讚！ | jason871021

+1

Translate to English: +1

(0) 讚！ | 123456789000000

Building thermal environment. 

2026.2.16 stj
2026.2.17 ur
2026.2.18 0-3-6 
2026.3.19 major revised Two reviewers, 30+ comments, difficult to respond, need to supplement experiments.
2026.4.5 revised to journal
2026.4.6 0-1-2 Only one reviewer accepted
2026.4.23 1-1-2 One reviewer's comments returned, editor accepted

(0) 讚！ | lvmazha

Strange, it has been two weeks since I reviewed an RRC, and mine has been pending for a week as well, but the editor has not processed it yet.

(1) 讚！ | ByRon

Do you have any friends who submitted their work in April? Why haven't we been reviewed yet?

(0) 讚！ | 先天论文圣体

From submission to publication, it only took 2 months, which was very fast!!! The editors were also very friendly. I forgot to submit the supplementary materials, but they quickly helped me with that.

(0) 讚！ | StacyDong

Submission on December 3, 2025.
Accepted on February 2, 2026.

Two reviewers, more than ten comments. The reviewers were quite meticulous and careful about the experimental section.

(0) 讚！ | sci-come

Why was I rejected the first time?

(0) 讚！ | 123456788888